1.
1980$BG/Be$K@/<#E/3X$N>l$G$O!"%j%Y%i%j%:%`$H!V6&F1BNJ$rB%$5$6$k$r$($J$+$C$?!"$H$$$&;v>p$,9M$($i$l$k(B[$BCm(B]$B!#(B
$B$7$+$72?$h$j$b%j%Y%i%j%:%`$H6&F1BN
$BNc$($P%5%s%G%k$O!"!VIi2Y$J$-<+8J(B (the unencumbered self)$B!W$H$$$&0u>](B
$BE*$JL?L>$K$h$C$F!"%j%Y%i%j%:%`$,A0Ds$H$7$F$$$k!V8D?M!W$N4QG0$rBP>]2=$7!"(B
$BHcH=$9$k!#FC$K$=$3$GHcH=$5$l$k$N$O%m!<%k%:$J$N$@$,!"$$$o$f$k@55A$N86M}(B
$B$rA*Br$9$k$KEv$?$C$F2f!9$,$=$3$K?H$r$*$+$M$P$J$i$J$$$H$$$&%m!<%k%:$N(B
$B!V86=i>uBV!W$NA[Dj$K$*$$$F!"2f!9$O<+$i$r$$$+$J$k6&F1BN$+$i$b!"$=$NFCDj(B
$B$NF;FAE*I3BS$+$i$b2r$-J|$A!"$5$i$K$O<+$i$N;}$DMM!9$J:b;:$d:MG=!"2ACM4Q(B
$B$d8DJL$JL\E*@_Dj$r6vA3E*$J$b$N$H$7$F9MN8$+$i30$7!"$?$@]$5$l$?$3$&$7$?!VIi2Y$J$-<+8J!W(B
$B$H$$$&A0Ds!J%5%s%G%k$K$h$l$P!V7A<)>e3XE*$J!WA0Ds!K$N$=$NCj>]@-$r>W$/$3(B
$B$H$K$h$C$F!"%5%s%G%k$O%m!<%k%:$N@55AO@$NCf?4$r$J$9!V@5(B ($B8"Mx(B right) $B$N(B
$BA1(B (good) $B$KBP$9$kM%@h!W$H$$$&%F!<%<$K0[5D$r>'$($k!#B($A!"%m!<%k%:$,6v(B
$BA3E*$J$b$N$H$7$F]$9$k>e=R$N8D?M$N:b$d=t@-$C$F2f!9$O!"<+$i$N%"%$%G%s%F%#%F%#!<(B
$B$r$=$3$K$*$$$FG'$a$k$C$F!V@5!W$N!VA1!W$KBP$9$kM%@h!"$H$$$&7A$G5,HO$r4pAC$E$1$k%m!<%k%:$N(B
$B5DO@$O<:GT$7$F$$$k!"$H%5%s%G%k$OO@$8$k$N$G$"$k!J(B Sandel, 1984. $B$^$?K\(B
$B9`Bh(B3$B@a$b;2>H$N$3$H!K!#(B
$B5DO@$rAH$_N)$F$k:]$N!V%"%k%-%a%G%9$N;YE@!W(B( Rawls, 1971, p.584) $B$H$7(B
$B$F%j%Y%i%j%:%`$,0M5r$9$k!"<+M3$G<+N)$7$?;TL1!"$H$$$&6aBeE*$Je$NAD7?$r%+%s%H$N!V1CCNE*<+8J!W(B
$B$K5a$a$F$3$l$KHcH=E*9M;!$r2C$(!"%F%$%i!<$O7
$B$G$O!"%j%Y%i%j%:%`$NE/3XE*F;6qN)$F$r$=$N5,HOE*HE*$K6&F1BNMNJ82=$H$$$&FCDj$N%?%$%W$NJ82=$K$*(B
$B$1$k$b$N$H$7$FAjBP2=$9$k$N$G$"$k(B(Taylor, 1979.)$B!J,Q(B$B!V%"%H%_%:%`!W(B)$B!#(B
$B2f!9$,=>$&$Y$-5,HO$r$3$&$7$FNr;KE*$J$b$N!"CO0hE*$J$b$N!"6vA3E*$J$b$N$K(B
$B0Q$M$k5DO@$O!"E/3XE*$K$O@5Ev2=$7$,$?$$$b$N$K;W$o$l$k!#$7$+$7!"$=$b$=$b(B
$B6&F1BN$O88A[$G$"$k!W$HCG$8$k(B (MacIntyre, pp.119,206 )$B!#(B
$B$3$l$KBP$7$F6&F1BN$7!"$=$3$K8+=P$5$l$k6&F1BNE*$JA1$r<+$i$N@8$NL\E*$H$7$F<+3PE*$K(B
$B0z$-u67(B
$B$E$1$i$l$?<+8J(B (the situated self)$B!W$H$O!"C1$K
2.
$BE/3XE*$JA0Ds$+$i5,HOE*
$B%j%Y%i%j%:%`$KBP$9$k6&F1BN$`8@MU$G$B!VFA$H6&F1BN!W(B$B!K!#6&F1BN2=$9$k$*$=$l$,$"$k$N$G$"$k!#(B
$BEvA3%j%Y%i%j%:%`$NB&$+$i$O!"6&F1BN$C$F6&F1BN'$($i$l$k$J$i!"$=$N>l9g$N!V6&F1BN!W$N35(B
$BG0$OEvA3$J$,$i$9$G$K5,HOE*$J35G0$G$"$j!"$7$+$b8=
$B%j%Y%i%j%:%`$NB&$+$i$N:FHcH=$K$h$C$FIb$-D&$j$K$5$l$?!"6&F1BN5A@-$K$D$$$F$O!"$_$:$+$i6&F1BN$l$,FbE*$J%G%#%l%s%^$rUT$s$G(B
$B$$$k!#$D$^$j!"$b$7:G=i$N5DO@$,@5$7$/%j%Y%i%k$JM}O@$,
$B$7$+$76&F1BNuBV$d!VL5(B
$BCN$N%Y!<%k!W$H$$$C$?F;6qN)$F$O7h$7$F7A<)>e3XE*$JA0Ds$J$N$G$O$J$/!"@/<#(B
$BE*$GEAE}E*$J35G0$H$7$F$N!V@55A!W$N$?$a$KF3F~$5$l$?$K$9$.$J$$!"$H$$$&$3(B
$B$H$rL@8@$7$F$$$k(B (Rawls, 1985)$B!#$3$&$7$?%m!<%k%:$N;Q@*$r;Y;}$9$k%m!<%F%#!<(B
$B$O!"!VE/3X$KBP$9$kL1J$9$k%&%)%k%D%!!<$O!"%j%Y%i%k$JO@l$+$i$N$_$3$l$rMJ8n$7$&$k!"$H$$$C(B
$B$?5DO@$rE83+$7$F$$$k(B (Walzer, 1981, p.394) $B!#$3$&$7$?4QE@$+$i$9$l$P!"(B
$B%5%s%G%k$N$h$&$J!VE/3XE*$J798~$r;}$C$?!WO@
$B%j%Y%i%j%:%`$H6&F1BNe3X(B
$BE*$J5DO@$+$i!"2f!9$,BgOH$K$*$$$F$=$NEAE}$rJ$H:Fe$2$F$$$k$3$H$,<($5$l$k$G$"$m$&!J,Q!VB?85J82=5$7$F9T$/$H$7$F$b!"6&F1BN/$J$/(B
$B$H$b$=$NJd40E*$JLr3d$K$h$C$F!"E/3XE*$K$b@/<#E*$K$b!"2f!9$,I,MW$H$;$6$k(B
$B$r$($J$$65@b$G$"$jB3$1$k$@$m$&!#!V6&F1BN
3.
$B0J2<$N3F9`$G$O!"6qBNE*$JO@E@$KB($7$F6&F1BN]E*$K$J$k$,$5$i$KN)$AF~$C$?J,@O$r9T$$!"$=$NE/3XE*$J(B
$B4^0U$r9M;!$9$k$3$H$G!"6&F1BN
$B$^$:F|>oE*$J8@8l463P$NLdBj$H$7$F!"!V@5!W$H$$$&$N$O$b$C$Q$i9T0Y$rI>2A$9(B
$B$k:]$K;H$&8@MU$G$"$k$N$KBP$7!J!V@5$7$$9T0Y!W!V@5$7$$H=CG!W!K!"!VA1!W$O(B
$B;vJ*0lHL$KBP$7$F7AMF;l$H$7$F;H$o$l$k8@MU$G$"$k!J!V$h$$K\!W!V$h$$
$B$7$+$7!"$3$l$@$1$G$O$^$@(B $B!V@5!W$H!VA1!W(B $B$N0c$$$NJ,@O$H$7$F$OIT==J,$G$"$k!#(B
$B$^$:!"!VA1!W$H$$$&35G0$O!VL\E*!W$H$$$&35G0$H?<$/7k$SIU$1$F;H$o$l$F$$$k!#(B
$B$H$$$&$N$b!"Nc$($P$"$k2A$N4p=`$r:NMQ$9$k$3$H$K$J$k$N$G$"$k!#Nc$((B
$B$P8yMxl9g$O$7$+$7!"2?$rL\E*$H$9$k$+!"2?$rK>$^$7$$$H9M$($k(B
$B$+$O?M$K$h$C$F!"$^$?6&F1BN$K$h$C$F@i:9K|JL$G$"$k$H9M$(!"!VA1!W$r6&F1BN(B
$B$dJ82=$KAjBPE*$J$b$N$H$_$J$7$F!"!V6&F1BN$NA1!J(Bcommunal good$B!K!W$HI=8=(B
$B$9$k!#$7$?$,$C$F9T0Y$NI>2A$O$3$N!V6&F1BN$NA1!W$K>H$i$7$FH=CG$5$l$k$3$H(B
$B$K$J$k$N$G$"$k!#(B
$B$5$F$3$l$KBP$7$F!"!V@5!W$H$$$&35G0$O!"!VA1!W$N35G0$HBPN)$9$k$b$N$H$7$F(B
$B9M$($k$H$-!"C1$K9T0Y$KBP$9$kH=CG$H$$$&$@$1$G$J$/!"A1$H$5$l$kL\E*$HFHN)(B
$B$K9T0Y$KBP$7$F2<$9H=CG$H$7$F$N@-3J$,6/D4$5$l$k$3$H$K$J$k!#$3$N$h$&$K$H(B
$B$i$($?$H$-!"!V@5!W$N35G0$O!V@55A(B (justice$B!K!W$N35G0$H6a$/$J$k!#(B($B!V@55A!W(B
$B$H$$$&35G0$OHs>o$KB?5AE*$G$"$k$,!"$3$N>l9g$O$H$j$o$1!V7A<0E*@55A!W$N35(B
$BG0$,6a$$!#(B)$B@55A$H$$$&35G0$NFbMF$N4pK\E*$JFCD'$N0l$D$H$7$F!"C/$+$r$R$$(B
$B$-$7$J$$!"CfN)E*$J$b$N$G$"$k!"8@$$$+$($k$H$9$Y$F$N?M$KJ?Ey$KG[N8$9$k$H(B
$B$$$&@-
$B$b$&0l$D;XE&$7$F$*$/I,MW$,$"$k$N$O!"!V8"Mx(B(rights)$B!W$H$$$&35G0$H@55A$H(B
$B$N4X$o$j$G$"$k!#@55A$N86M}$O$?$$$F$$$N>l9g!"C/$+$K8"Mx$rM?$(!"B>?M$K$=(B
$B$N8"Mx$rB:=E$9$k5AL3$rIi$o$;$k$H$$$&7A$rl9g(B
$B$K$O0lI<$rEj$8$k8"Mx$G$"$j!"G[J,$N@55A$N>l9g$K$O<+J,$KAj1~$J$b$N$ro$K7A<0E*$J0UL#$G$N!V@5(B
$B5A!W$K6a$$0UL#$G;HMQ$5$l$F$$$k$H9M$($i$l$k!#(B
$B0J>e$N3NG'$7$?$h$&$J!V@5!W$H!VA1!W$N35G0FbMF$K4p$E$$$F!"%j%Y%i%j%:%`!&(B
$B6&F1BNW(B
$BFM$9$k>l9g$r9M$($F$_$l$P$h$$!#?M$K$h$C$F2?$rA1$H$9$k$+$O0c$&$N$@$+$i!"(B
$B$=$N$h$&$JA1$N$I$l$+$K$b$H$E$$$FD4Dd$r9T$*$&$H$7$F$b$&$^$/$$$/$O$:$,$J(B
$B$$!#$7$?$,$C$F$o$l$o$l$O$=$&$7$?A1$+$iFHN)$K@55A$N86M}$rN)$F!"$=$l$K$7(B
$B$?$,$C$F3F?M$NL\E*$r5,@)$7$J$/$F$O$J$i$J$$$3$H$K$J$k!#(B
$B$3$l$KBP$7$F6&F1BNe$K=R$Y$?$h$&$J!V@5!W$K4p$E(B
$B$/H=CG$r2<$98D?M$b$^$?!"FCDj$N6&F1BN$KB0$7!"FCDj$NA1$dL\E*$r$9$G$K<+J,(B
$B$NFb$K;}$C$F$$$k!#H`$i$N2ACMH=CG$N4pAC$K$O!"$3$&$7$?A1$N9M$(J}$dL\E*$,(B
$B$"$k!#$7$?$,$C$F!"2?$,!V@5$7$$!W$+$NH=CG$b$^$?$3$l$i$NA1$dL\E*$+$iFHN)(B
$B$G$O$"$j$($J$$!#$b$A$m$s!"<+M3
[ $BJ88%(B ]
- Friedman, M.,"Feminism and Modern Friendship: Dislocating the Community", Ethics, 99, [1989], 275-290.$B!J"(!K(B
- Gutmann, A.,"Communitarian Critics of Liberalism", Philosophy and Public Affairs, [1985], 308-322.$B!J"(!K(B
- Kymlicka, W.,"Community", in Goodin, R. E. and Pettit, P. (eds.), A Companion to Contemporary Political Philosophy, Basil Blackwell Ltd., [1993], 366-378.
-
MacIntyre, A.,After Virtue, G. Duckworth & Co. Ltd. [1981].($BK.Lu!XH~FA$J$-;~Be!Y(B($B
Rawls, J., A Theory of Justice, Harvard University Press, [1971].($BK.Lu!X@55AO@!Y(B($BLpEg6V
$B!=(B , "Justice as Fairness: Political Not Metaphysical", Philosophy and Public Affairs, [1985], 223-239.$B!J"(!K(B
-
Rorty, R., "The Priority of Democracy to Philosophy", Philosophical Papers I , Cambridge University Press, [1991], 175-196.($BK.Lu!VE/3X$KBP$9$kL1
Sandel, M., Liberalism and the Limits of Justice, Cambridge University Press,[1982]. ($BK.Lu!X<+M3
$B!=(B ,"The Procedual Republic and the Unencumbered Self", Political Theory, vol. 12, [1984], 81-96.$B!J"(!K(B
-
Taylor, Ch., "Atomism", Philosophy and the Human Science: Philosophical Papers 2, Cambridge University Press, [1985], 187-210.$B!J"(!K(B
-
Walzer, M., "Philosophy and Democracy", Political Theory, vol. 9, [1981], 379-399.
-
$B!=(B , "The Communitarian Critique of Liberalism", Political Theory, vol. 18, [1990], 6-23.
$B!J"(!K$O!"(BAvineri, S. and de-Shalit, A. (eds.), Communitarianism and Individual-ism, Oxford University Press [1992] $B$K=j<}$N$b$N$G!"0zMQJG$O$3$NO@=8$K5r$C$?!#$3$NO@=8$O!"6&F1BN
$B!J(B1$B!"(B 2 $B$7$m$&$:(B $B$7$m$&(B $B5~ETBg3XJ83XIt8&=$0w!K(B
$B!J(B3 $B$$$;$@(B $B$F$D$8(B $BGn;N8e4|2]Dx;02s@8(B $B!K(B
$B!X©(copy right) 1994, $B
Dept. of EThics <ethics@socio.kyoto-u.ac.jp>
Last modified: Tue Mar 12 07:15:24 JST 1996