$B%\%/$K$h$l$P!"FbIt9pH/pJs$rK=O*$9$k$3$H$G8x6&$NMx1W$r6<$+$9$h$&$J2a<:$d4m81$KBP$7$FCm0U$rB%$=$&$H$9$k?M!9$N8F>N$G$"$k!#H`$i$O!"<+J,$NAH?%$NFbIt$+$i!"<+J,$N@lLgE*$JCN<1$dFbIt>pJs$K4p$E$$$F7Y9p$rH/$9$k!#EvA3!"AH?%$N5!L);v9`$rK=O*$9$k$H$$$C$?$?$0$$$N$3$&$7$?9T0Y$K$O%j%9%/$,$D$-$b$N$G$"$k!#$^$:Bh0l$K!"$3$NAH?%$,?J9T$5$;$F$$$k6HL3$N287C$KM?$+$C$F$$$k?M!9!"$D$^$j<+J,$N2qr$G$O!"8x6&$N0BA4@-!"7r9/!"J!;c$r6<$+$9$h$&$J0-J@$KBP$7$F9pH/$r$9$k$3$H$,$=$N3X2q$N%a%s%P!<$K5a$a$i$l$F$$$k!#B?$/$N>&l$K$$$J$,$i4m81$rL[;&$7<+J,$b6&HH$N@UG$$r$+$V$k$+!"$5$^$6$^$J3kF#$d%W%l%C%7%c!<$,FbIt9pH/$N%V%l!<%-%7%9%F%`$K%;%-%e%j%F%#!<>e$N7g4Y$,$"$k$3$H$rK=O*$9$k%(%s%8%K%"!#9)>l$N$4$_=8@Q>l6a$/$N1?F0>l$KM-32$J2=3X@=IJ$,O3$l=P$7$F$$$k$3$H$r8x$K$9$k;:6HO+F/
$BFbIt9pH/$r$H$j$^$/;0$D$NMWAG(B
$B8=>uBGGK$r$M$i$&FbIt9pH/$K$O!"0l
$B$^$:Bh0l$K!"FbIt9pH/$K$O!"0[5DI=L@(B(dissent)$B$H$$$&B&LL$,$"$k$H$5$l$k!#$D$^$j0[5DI=L@$H$O!"8"0R$dBgB??t$H$N0U8+$NIT0lCW$r8x$K$9$k$3$H$G$"$k!#$?$@!"FbIt9pH/$K$*$1$k0[5DI=L@$O!"=!65E*655A$d@/<#J}?K$d5D2q7hDj$J$I$X$NIT0lCW$H$$$C$?0lHL$N0[5DI=L@$H$O0[$J$j!"2a<:$d0-J@$rK=O*$7$?$j!"8x=0$K4m81$r9pCN$7$?$j!"$=$N4m81$KBP$9$k@UG$$r2]$7$?$j$9$k$H$$$C$?$4$/69$$L\E*$@$1$K8B$i$l$?$b$N$G$"$k!#FbIt9pH/$K$H$C$Fe$N0[5DI=L@$rI=L@$9$k$?$a$KFbIt9pH/$9$k$b$N$@$+$i$G$"$k!#$=$NNc$H$7$F5s$2$i$l$F$$$k$N$O!"JF9q9qKIAm>J$N=qN`$K4X$9$k@/<#$N13$dA`:n$rK=O*$7$?%@%K%(%k!&%(%k%9%P!<%0$N9T0Y$G$"$k!#%\%/$K$h$l$P!"H`$NL\E*$O!"IT@54IM}(B(misconduct)$B$rK=O*$7$F@UG$$rDI5Z$9$k$3$H$@$1$G$O$J$/!"ElFn%"%8%"$KBP$9$k9q2H@/:v$K1F6A$rM?$($k$3$H$K$b$"$C$?$H$$$&$N$G$"$k!#(B
$BBhFs$NMWAG$G$"$kCi@??4$NITMz9T(B(breach of loyalty)$B$H$O!"K\Mh$J$i2L$?$5$l$k$Y$-8[MQl$N?M4V$,!"<+J,$N%A!<%`$K%{%$%C%9%k$rLD$i$9$H$$$&$o$1$G$"$k!#FbIt$H$$$&N)>l$K$O!"F1N=$d8\5R$KBP$9$k5AL3$,H<$&$b$N$G$"$k!#$3$H$K$h$k$H!"FbIt9pH/WFM$9$k$3$H$K$J$k$N$G$"$k!#%\%/$K$h$l$P!"$3$l$3$=$,!"FbIt$+$i$N9pH/$H!"It30
$BBh;0$K!"FbIt$+$i!VH?B'!W$r6+$V5jCF(B(accusation)$B$H$$$&MWAG$,!"FbIt9pH/$K$OIU?o$7$F$$$k$H$5$l$k!#$3$l$O!"HsF;FAE*$J9T0Y$dITK!9T0Y$N@UG$$r$"$kFCDj$NF1N=$J$$$7$O>e;J$NB&$K2]$9$3$H!"L@<(E*$G$"$l0EL[E*$G$"$l!"FCDj$N%0%k!<%W$d8D?M$K@UG$$r2]$9$3$H$G$"$k!#2?$,0-$+$C$?$N$+!"2?$,4m81$@$C$?$+$rCN$C$F$$$??M!9!"$b$7$/$OCN$C$F$$$J$/$F$O$J$i$J$+$C$??M!9!"JL$NA*Br$r$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$??M!9$J$I$,$=$l$K$"$?$k!#$D$^$j!"$=$N@UG$$O!"D>@\E*$K2]$5$l$k$@$1$G$J$/!"FCDj2=$7$F2]$5$l$J$/$F$O$J$i$J$$$N$G$"$k!#$?$H$($P<+A3:R32(B($B$?$H$($P:9$7Gw$C$?@cJx$d2P;3$NJ.2P$J$I(B)$B$N$h$&$K!"C/$b4m81$KBP$9$k@UG$$r/$J$+$lHkL)$,o$G$"$j!"30It$N?M4V$,$[$H$s$ICN$j$($J$$@-e$G=R$Y$?!"0[5DI=L@!"Ci@??4$NITMz9T!"5jCF$H$$$&;0$D$NMWAG$N$?$a$K!"FbIt9pH/WF0$,!"$$$C$=$&6[D%$NEY$r6/$a$F$$$k$H;XE&$7$F$$$k!#$=$N0lJ}$G!"%\%/$O!"FbIt9pH/2A$7$F$$$k$+$H$$$&$3$H$K$b8@5Z$7$F$$$k!#$D$^$j!"F1N=$?$A$O!"FbIt9pH/20eNE8&5f$K$*$1$kIT@5J}!"FbIt9pH/2A$O!"N>J}$K%P%$%"%9$,$+$+$C$F$$$k$H$$$&$b$N$G!"FbIt9pH/p$O<($7$D$D$b!"$3$3$G$O!"$$$:$l$NN)>l$K$b;?@.$7$J$$CfN)E*$JBVEY$r8G;}$7$h$&$H$7$F$$$k!#(B
$B5!L)O31L
$B5!L)O31L$O!"FbIt9pH/$HF1$8$/!"@/<#!"CNE*?&6H!"2J3X!"%S%8%M%9$NJ,Ln$K$*$1$kHkL)87l9g$b$"$k$,!"$?$@$=$l$i$,!"8m$C$?>pJs$@$C$?$j!"0-0U$"$k8D?M967b$G$"$C$?$j$9$k>l9g$b>/$J$/$J$$!#$=$3$G!"8x6&$NMx1W$rl9g!"$3$NN>r$d@-@83h$H$$$C$?%W%i%$%t%'!<%H$J;vJA$r07$&$J$i$P!"FbIt9pH/$d5!L)O31L$O!"$*$=$i$/$^$C$?$/ITE,@Z$J$b$N$@$m$&!#FbIt9pH/$b5!L)O31L$b!"IT@5$J2J3X8&5f$d@/<#E*%i%$%t%!%k$?$A$X$N6
$BOQ4_9bB.N95RM"Aw%7%9%F%`(B(BART)$B$K$*$1$kFbIt9pH/(B
$B$3$l$O!"(B1952$BG/$+$iCe%3%s%H%m!<%k!&%7%9%F%`$@$C$?!#$7$+$7$3$N;0?M$N%(%s%8%K%"$?$A$O3F!9!"(B1969$BG/$4$m$+$i=y!9$K!"$3$N%7%9%F%`$N%V%l!<%-%7%9%F%`$N0BA4@-$K$D$$$F5?Ld$rJz$-$O$8$a$F$$$?!#8=>l4FFD41$d(BBART$B$N4IM}e$N7W2h$NCY$l$KG:$^$5$l$F$$$?$?$a$K7g4Y$ND4::$rBU$C$?!#%(%s%8%K%"$?$A$O!"(BBART$B$NM};v2q$K$3$NLdBj$re$2$F$b$i$&$?$a$K?TNO$7$?$,!"$d$O$j$3$l$b<:GT$7$?!#(B1973$BG/(B3$B7n!"AJ$($,$3$N;0?M$N%(%s%8%K%"$+$i=P$5$l$?$b$N$@$H$o$+$k$d!"H`$i$O!"FCJL$JM}M3$b$J$/2r8[$5$l$?!#$=$&$7$F$$$k$"$$$@$K(BBART$B$N%7%9%F%`$,5/F0$7;O$a$?$,!"H`$i$,M=4|$7$F$$$?$h$&$K!"$3$N%7%9%F%`$O$-$o$a$F4m81$J$b$N$G!"3+DL0l%v7n$G!"Nsl$K>h$j>e$2$k$H$$$&;v8N$,H/@8$7$?!#(B1972$BG/!";0?M$N%(%s%8%K%"$?$A$,%+%j%U%)%k%K%"@lLg2H%(%s%8%K%"6(2q$K=u$1$r5a$a$k$H!"6(2q$O$=$NAJ$($rD4::$7$FH`$i$N8+2r$r;Y;}$7!"%+%j%U%)%k%K%"=#5D2q$KJs9p$7$?!#$=$N8e!"%+%j%U%)%k%K%"=#5D2q$b$^$?D4::$K>h$j=P$7!"(BBART$B$N4IM}$,$-$o$a$F4m81$J$b$N$G$"$k$H$N7kO@$r2<$7$?!#%(%s%8%K%"$?$A$O(B1974$BG/$K(BBART$B$rAjY$r5/$3$7$?$,!"(B1975$BG/$K<(CL$G2r7h$7$?!#H`$i$O!"$J$+$J$+?7$7$$?&>l$r8+$D$1$k$3$H$,$G$-$:!"8x$N;Y;}$,$"$C$?$K$b$+$+$o$i$:!":b@/E*$K$b46>pE*$K$b$+$J$j$N6lDK$K6l$7$`$3$H$K$J$C$?!#0J>e$,$3$N;vNc$NBgN,$@$,!"%\%/$O!"$3$N;0?M$N%(%s%8%K%"$?$A$,<+J,$N@lLgE*$JCN<1$K4p$E$$$F%3%s%H%m!<%k!&%7%9%F%`>e$N7g4Y$rK=O*$7$?$3$H$K$h$j!"K!N'$d%(%s%8%K%"NQM}9KNN$KB($7$?9TF0$r$H$C$F$$$k$HF1;~$K!"0lHL$N?M$K$O$o$+$i$J$$4m81$KBP$7$F7Y9p$rH/$9$k$H$$$&@lLg2H8GM-$NFCJL$J@UG$$K$b1~$($F$$$k$H$$$&!#$G$O!"L@3N$JNX3T$r$b$D$3$NNc$r
$B%[%$%C%9%k$rLD$i$9$+!VF]$_2<$9$+!W$NA*Br(B
$BFbIt9pH/$r$9$Y$-$+H]$+$rA*Br$9$k$5$$$K$b!">e$G=R$Y$?0[5DI=L@!"Ci@?$NITMz9T!"5jCF$H$$$&;0$D$NMWAG$,Lr$KN)$D$H%\%/$O9M$($k!#$D$^$j!"<+J,$,L\7b$7$?LdBj$rK=O*$9$k$+$I$&$+$r7hCG$9$k$H$-$K$O!"$=$NFbIt9pH/$K$h$k0[5DI=L@$r$9$k$+$I$&$+$NH=CG$H$=$N@53N$5!"Ci@?$NITMz9T$r:G>.8BEY$K$H$I$a$k$h$&$JJL$NA*Br;h$rC5$k$3$H!"5jCF$,$b$D8x@5$5!"$3$N;0$D$,MW5a$5$l$k$H$$$&$N$G$"$k!#$^$:!"0[5DI=L@$r$9$k$+$I$&$+$NH=CG$H$=$N@53N$5$,8!F$$5$l$k!#FbIt9pH/$r$9$k$N$,EvA3$J>l9g!"$=$l$K$O$U$5$o$7$/$J$$>l9g!"FM$-;_$a$k$3$H$,:$Fq$J$?$a$K!"$=$l$K$O;~4|>0Aa$G$"$k$h$&$J>l9g!#$3$l$i$N4V$GFbIt9pH/R2p$9$k!#$3$NJ[8n;N$O!"<+J,$,8\Ld$r$D$H$a$k2qZ5r$O$"$,$i$J$+$C$?$H8@$$!"LdBj$N=j:_$r$D$-$H$a$h$&$H$9$kJ[8n;N$KBP$9$k$$$i$@$A$r<($7$F$$$k$h$&$K8+$($?!#$3$N;vNc$N>l9g!"%\%/$O!"FbIt9pH/$r$9$k$@$1$N>Z5r$O$^$@==J,$G$O$J$$$H9M$($k!#$H$$$&$N$b!"@lLgE*$JCN<1$K$h$C$F%v%l!<%-!&%7%9%F%`$N7g4Y$r8+H4$$$?(BBART$B$N%(%s%8%K%"$N>l9g$H$O0[$J$j!"$3$NJ[8n;N$O!"$^$@<+J,$N8@$$J,$K3N?.$rJz$$$F$$$J$$$+$i$G$"$k!#%(%s%8%K%"$N9T0Y$O!"4m81$KCm0U$rB%$9$3$H$,<+J,$N5AL3$G$"$j!"@lLgE*$JCN<1$r$b$F$PB>$NC/$G$b$=$N4m81$r8+1[$9$3$H$,$G$-$k$H$$$&ZL@$5$l$F$$$k$o$1$G$O$J$$!#$3$N?M9)F)@O5!3#$K$h$kF~1!Cf$N45ZL@$7!"$=$N>e$G9TF0$K=P$kI,MW$,$"$k$H$$$&$N$G$"$k!#%\%/$,!"$3$N;vNc$,FbIt9pH/$K$O$^$@IT==J,$G$"$k$H$$$&$N$O!"0J>e$N$h$&$JM}M3$K$h$k$N$G$"$k!#$3$NJ[8n;N$N;vNc$O!"<+l9g!"8D?M$J$$$7AH?%$KB?Bg$J%@%a!<%8$,M?$($i$l$k$?$a!"$3$l$+$iFbIt9pH/$7$h$&$H$9$k?M$O!"$^$:.8BEY$K$H$I$a$k$?$a$K$O$I$&$9$l$P$$$$$N$+$,8!F$$5$l$k!#$7$+$7!"$=$l$O!"$I$A$i$NCi@??4$rM%@h$5$;$k$N$+$H$$$&LdBj$G$"$k$H$5$l$k!#$$$/$D$+$N@lLg2HNQM}9KNN$N$J$+$G$O!"$9$/$J$/$H$bM}O@>e$O!"$$$D$J$s$I$->WFM$,@8$8$F$b!"F1N=$d8[MQ$K$J$$$+$I$&$+$r==J,$KLO:w$7$F$*$/$3$H$bI,MW$@$H$$$&!#FbIt$N?M$N1g=u$r6D$0$3$H$K$h$C$F!"$7$P$7$P8x=0$NMx1W$HFbIt$N?M$x$NN>J}$NCi@?$r;Y;}$7$J$,$i!"AH?%FbIt$G$NLdBj2r7h$b2DG=$H$J$k$H$$$&!#:G=i$+$i$&$k$5$/7Y>b$rLD$i$7$^$o$k$h$&$J9T0Y$O!"F1N=$d8[MQ$NA*Br;h$,=P?T$/$7$F5qH]$5$l$?>l9g$d!"DL>o$Nl9g$K$@$1A*Br$5$l$J$/$F$O$J$i$J$$!#$5$i$K$^$?!"l9g$b$"$k$H$$$&$b$N$G$"$k!#$7$?$,$C$F!".8B$K$H$I$a$?:GNI$Nl9g$K:G$b6/$/$J$k$b$N$@$H$5$l$k!#$H$/$K4IM}l9g$K5jCF$O@8$8$k$H=R$Y$i$l$F$$$k!#:G8e$K!"%\%/$O!"FbIt9pH/$N;?@.O@$HH?BPO@$NN>J}$N=E$_$r$O$+$k$h$&$J$h$j0lHLE*$J
$B>R2p
$B0J>e8+$F$-$?$h$&$K!"%\%/$O!"$3$NO@J8$N$J$+$G(B$B0[5DI=L@(B(I%(B$BCi@??4$NITMz9T(B(I%(B$B5jCF(B$B$H$$$&FbIt9pH/$N;0$D$NMWAG$r<4$K!"@5Ev$JFbIt9pH/$r$9$k$?$a$N;X?K$rDs<($7$h$&$H$7$F$$$k!#$=$7$F!"(BBART$B$N%(%s%8%K%"$?$A$K$h$kFbIt9pH/$r!"$3$N;X?K$rDs6!$9$kE57?E*$J%1!<%9$H5,Dj$7$F$$$k!#5DO@$N6ZF;$,!"$O$?$7$F$=$NOHAH$_$H$&$^$/@09g$7$FE83+$5$l$F$$$k$+$I$&$+$H$$$&E@$K$O5?Ld$,;D$k$H$O$$$(!"$5$^$6$^$JMW0x$,Mm$_9g$&FbIt9pH/$H$$$&;v>]$,!"Hf3SE*$9$C$-$j$H$7$?7A$G$^$H$a$i$l$F$$$k$h$&$K;W$o$l$k!#$?$@(BBART$B$NNc$G$bLdBj$H$7$F;D$C$F$$$?$3$H$@$,!"FbIt9pH/$7$?8e$K9pH/l$KBP$9$k%U%)%m!<$,$I$N$h$&$K$J$5$l$&$k$N$+$H$$$&E@$r!"$3$3$G$N%\%/$OEy4W$K$U$7$F$7$^$C$F$$$k!#FbIt9pH/$r7h0U$9$k$^$G$N3kF#$O$b$A$m$s$@$,!"$"$k$$$O$=$l0J>e$K!"FbIt9pH/8e$N9pH/$r$U$;$F!"%^%9%3%_$d8xE*$J5!4X$K>pJs$rN.$7$F30It$+$i$ND4::$rM6H/$9$k$H$$$C$?JL$N
$B!JB?2l7rB@O:!K(B
1 Sissela Bok, "The Morality of Whistle-Blowing" in Computers, Ethics, and Society (ed. by M. David Ermann, Mary B. Williams and Michele S. Shauf, Oxford, 1997)
$BL\
Last modified: Wed Jan 12 16:54:38 JST 2000