$B%W%i%$%P%7!<$HK!$N8B3&(B1

$B%k!<%9!&%2%$%S%=%s(B

$B%-!<%o!<%I(B

$B$3$NO@J8$O!"%$%'!<%k!&%m!

$BGX7J$HJ}?K(B

$B%W%i%$%P%7!<4XO"$NAJ>Y$,G'$a$i$l!"(B1974$BG/%W%i%$%P%7!o$N9M$(J}$,MJ8n$5$l$F$$$k!#(B

$B2f!9$O%W%i%$%P%7!<$rM-MQ$J(B(useful)$B35G0$@$H9M$($F$$$k!#M-MQ$G$"$k$?$a$K$O!"$=$N35G0$OH=L@$G(B(distinct)$B0l4S$7$?(B(coherent)$B2?$+$r0UL#$7$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$!#$=$N:]!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$O

$BDL>o!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$O$3$l$i;0$D$NJ8L.$K$*$$$FY2DG=$J?/32(B((3)$B$K$h$jF1Dj(B)$B$,!"$=$l$>$lAj8_$K4X$o$k$H9M$($i$l$F$$$k!#$3$&$7$?7k$S$D$-$rMJ8n$9$k$3$H$G!"K!E*J]8n$NMW@A$d$=$l$,K~$?$5$l$kDxEY$r$h$j$h$/M}2r$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#(B

$BO@J8$N35N,(B

1) [$B%W%i%$%P%7!<$NCfN)E*$J35G0(B] $B$3$3$G$O!"(B(1)$B%W%i%$%P%7!<$H$$$&8l$N0LCV$E$1$K4X$9$kLdBj(B(1-1)$B!"(B(2)$B%W%i%$%P%7!<$NFCD'$K4X$9$kLdBj(B(1-2)$B$,O@$8$i$l$k!#$=$7$F!"2f!9$N%W%i%$%P%7!<$KBP$9$k4X?4$O!"B>?M$K$H$C$F$N@\6a2DG=@-(B(accessibility)($B2f!9$OB>?M$K$I$NDxEYCN$i$l$F$$$k$N$+(B(1-2-1)$B!"2f!9$O$I$NDxEYB>?M$NCm0U$NBP>]$G$"$k$N$+(B(1-2-2)$B!"B>?M$O2f!9$K?HBNE*$K$I$NDxEY@\6a$9$k$N$+(B(1-2-3))$B$KBP$9$k4X?4$K4X$o$k!#$3$N$h$&$K%W%i%$%P%7!<$rB*$($k$3$H$G!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$NAS<:$N;~E@$r8+6K$a$i$l$k!#$=$N:]!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$N35G0$H2ACM$O6hJL$5$l$M$P$J$i$J$$!#2ACM$NLdBj$r@h

2) [$B%W%i%$%P%7!$^$7$/$J$$$H9M$($kM}M3$NN`;w@-(B] $B0[$J$k>u672<$G$"$C$F$b%W%i%$%P%7!<$r5a$a$kM}M3$ON`;w$7$F$$$k!#$=$&$7$?M}M3$O!"2f!9$N@83h$K$*$1$k%W%i%$%P%7!<$N5!G=(B($B<+M3!"<+N'!"8D@-!"?M4V4X78$NB%?J(B(2-1)$B!"5Z$S!"<+M3$J

3) [$B%W%i%$%P%7!<$NK!E*J]8n(B] 1)$B$H(B2)$B$K$h$j!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$O!"K!BN7O$K$h$C$F!"9MN8$5$l$k$Y$-2ACM$H$7$FL@<(E*$K;Y;}(B(explicit commitment)$B$5$l$M$P$J$i$J$$!"$H$$$&8+2r$,MJ8n$5$l$k!#$=$N:]!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$OB>$N2?$i$+$NMx1W$rH<$o$J$1$l$PJ]8n$5$l$J$$$H$$$&;v

$B%W%i%$%P%7!<$NCfN)E*$J35G0(B

$B%W%i%$%P%7!<$N0LCV$E$1(B

$B%W%i%$%P%7!<$O>u67$+!"8"Mx$+!"MW5a$+!";YG[(B(control)$B$N0l7ABV$+!#MW5a!"?4M}>uBV!"?/32$5$l$k$Y$-$G$J$$NN0h$H$7$F%W%i%$%P%7!<$rB*$($k$N$O!"2ACM$,Ii2Y$5$l$F$7$^$C$F$$$k$?$a!"CfN)E*$J35G0$H$7$F$U$5$o$7$/$J$$!#(B

$B$G$O!";YG[$N0l7ABV$H$7$FB*$($k$3$H$O$G$-$k$N$@$m$&$+!#%W%i%$%P%7!<$r!V8D?ME*$J;vJA$K4X$9$kCN<1$N;YG[!W$HDj5A$7$F$_$h$&!#;YG[$rpJs3+<($O!"$=$N>pJs$r;YG[$7$F$$$k$3$H$K$J$k$+$i!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$NAS<:$r>7$+$J$$$3$H$K$J$k!#B>J}!"6/$$0UL#$GB*$($l$P!"0U;V$K$h$k>pJs3+<($O!"$=$l0J9_$N>pJs3H;6$rAK$`NO$r<:$&$N$@$+$i!";YG[$NAS<:$G$"$k!#$3$N$h$&$K;YG[$H$7$FB*$($i$l$?>l9g!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$NAS<:$O$"$$$^$$$K$J$k!#(B

$B$5$i$K!";YG[$H$7$FDj5A$5$l$?%W%i%$%P%7!<$O2?$i$+$NA*Br$r9T$&NO$K4X$o$k!#$@$,!"?M$O%W%i%$%P%7!<$r;}$?$J$$$3$H$rA*Br$9$k$+$bCN$l$J$$!#<+J,$K4X$9$k>pJs$r$9$Y$F3+<($9$k$3$H$rA*Br$7$??M$O!"<+J,$N>pJs$r;YG[$7$?7k2L!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$rAS<:$9$k$3$H$K$J$k!#$^$?!"2f!9$,%W%i%$%P%7!<$rI>2A$9$kM}M3$b!"8D?M$N

$B$7$?$,$C$F!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$O;YG[$N0l7ABV$G$O$J$$!#7k6I!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$N35G0$r2ACMIi2YE*$J$b$N$K$7$J$$$?$a$K$O!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$r!"B>?M$KBP$9$k8D?M$N>u67$d@83h$N>r7o$@$H8+$k$N$,$h$$!#(B

$B%W%i%$%P%7!<$NFCD'(B

$B%W%i%$%P%7!<$O!"8D?M$N>pJs$XB>?M$,@\6a$9$k$3$H$N@)8B$G$"$k!#J}K!O@>e$N=PH/E@$H$7$F!"$"$k?M$,B>?M$+$i$^$C$?$/@\6a$5$lF@$J$$>l9g$K!"$=$N?M$O40A4$J%W%i%$%P%7!<$r5}pJs$r2?0l$D;}$?$J$$(B($BHkL)@-(B(secrecy))$B$7!"(B(2)$BC/$b(BX$B$K2?$NCm0U$bJ'$o$J$$(B($BF?L>@-(B(anonymity))$B$7!"(B(3)$BC/$b(BX$B$K?HBNE*$K@\6a$7$J$$(B($BFH5o@-(B(solitude))$B!#EvA3$J$,$i!"40A4$J%W%i%$%P%7!<$O8=pJs$r;}$A!"(B(2)$BC/$+$,(BX$B$K2?$i$+$NCm0U$rJ'$$!"(B(3)$BC/$+$,(BX$B$K?HBNE*$K@\6a$9$k!#$3$l$i(B3$B$D$NMWAG$OJL$N$b$N$G$"$j$J$,$iO"4X$79g$C$F$$$k!#(B

$B8D?M$K4X$7$FCN$i$l$k>pJs(B

$B%W%i%$%P%7!<$O!"8D?M$K$D$$$FCN$i$l$k>pJs$NAmNL$K4X$o$k!#!V>pJs$NAmNL!W$rLdBj$K$9$k0J>e!">pJs$N9`L\$N8DJL2=!"(BX$B$K4X$9$k>pJs$N9`L\$N$=$l$>$l$rCN$k?M4V$N?t$N7hDj!"$=$&$7$?>pJs$NNL$N7WNL2DG=@-$,LdBj$H$J$k!#pJs$NAmNL$H$$$&8+J}$+$iLdBj$r9M;!$9$k$N$OM-1W$G$"$k!#(B

$BLdBj(B1$B!'(B $B2f!9$O8D?M$K4X$9$k>pJs$N

$BNc$($P!"(BY$B$O!"(BX$B$K4X$9$k8@MU$K$h$k5-=R$rFI$s$G!"!V(BX$B$O%O%2$@!W$HCN$k!#$=$N8e$G!"(BY$B$O(BX$B$r8+$F!"(BX$B$O%O%2$@$H4Q;!$9$k!#$5$F!"$3$N;~!"(BY$B$O(BX$B$K$D$$$F?7$?$J>pJs$rF@$?$N$+!#$b$7F@$?$J$i$=$l$O2?$J$N$+!#$^$?!"(BY$B$O!"8@MU$K$h$k5-=R$rFI$_D>$7$F$b!"(BX$B$K4X$9$k?7$?$J>pJs$rF@$k$+$bCN$l$J$$!#(B

$BLdBj(B2$B!'(B X$B$K$D$$$FC/$,$h$jB?$/$N>pJs$r;}$C$F$$$k$N$+!#(B($BF10l8D?M$K4X$9$kCN<1$N!VAmNL!W$NHf3S$NLdBj(B)

$BLdBj(B3$B!'(B $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$NAS<:$,@8$8$k$K$O!">pJs$O8D?M$K4X$9$k$b$N$G$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$!#(B

$B>pJs$H8D?M$N4X78$O$I$NDxEYFC

$B$"$k%0%k!<%W$N?M!9$NHkL)$K$D$$$F>\:Y$J>pJs$rF@$F$$$F!"$=$N8e!"$=$N%0%k!<%W$KB0$9$k$"$k?M$K>R2p$5$l$?>l9g!"0lHLE*$J>pJs$,8D?ME*$J>pJs$KJQ2=$9$k$3$H$G%W%i%$%P%7!<$NAS<:$,@8$8$k$N$+(B2$B!#(B($B;J:W$N0oOC!'(B $B$"$k%Q!<%F%#$G;J:W$,!V;d$,=i$a$FJ9$$$?9pGr$O;&?M$K4X$9$k$b$N$G$7$?!W$H8l$C$F$$$?!#?tJ,8e!">eIJ$JCK$,$d$C$F$-$F;J:W$K63$7$/0';"$r$7$?!#$I$&$7$F;J:W$HCN$j9g$C$?$N$G$9$+!"$HLd$o$l$F$=$NCK$O!V;d$OH`$K:G=i$K9pGr$9$k1IM@$rF@$?$N$G$9!W$H8@$C$?!#$3$N>l9g!";J:W$OF?L>$N>pJs$rDs6!$7$?$N$@$,!"9pGr$N8@L@$H7k$S$D$$$F!"$"$k?M$K4X$9$k>pJs$K$J$C$?$N$G$"$k!#(B)

X$B$N:J!"?F!"8$$K4X$9$k>pJs$O(BX$B$K4X$9$k>pJs$+!#(B($B?M!9$N<+J,<+?H$K4X$9$k9M$($O!"<+$i$N?HBN$N6-3&$r1[$($F3HD%$5$l$F$$$k$3$H$,$"$k!#(B)

$BLdBj(B4$B!'(B X$B$K4X$9$k8m$C$?>pJs$N3H;6(B3$B$O!"H`$,%W%i%$%P%7!<$r<:$&$3$H$r0UL#$9$k$N$+!#(B($BJ9$-@-$r<:$$CmL\$5$l$k$N$G!"$=$N0UL#$G$O(BX$B$O%W%i%$%P%7!<$rAS<:$9$k!#0lJ}!"(BX$B$K$D$$$F@5$7$$$3$H$OCN$i$l$F$$$J$$$N$@$+$i!"pJs$OCN$i$l$J$$$^$^$G$"$j!"$=$N0UL#$G$O(BX$B$O%W%i%$%P%7!<$rAS<:$7$F$$$J$$!#(B)

$B8D?M$KBP$7$FJ'$o$l$kCm0U(B

$B8D?M$OCmL\$5$l$k$H>o$K%W%i%$%P%7!<$rAS<:$9$k!#Cm0U$O!">pJs$rF@$k:G=i$NJ}K!$G$"$j!";~$H$7$F>pJs3MF@$NK\7$/$3$H$b$"$k!#$*G&$S$GJb$$$F$$$kBgE}NN$K8~$+$C$F!"!V$"$C!"BgE}NN$@!W$H8F$S$+$1$l$P!"BgE}NN$OF?L>@-$K$h$C$FF@$F$$$?%W%i%$%P%7!<$rAS<:$9$k!#(B

$B8D?M$KBP$9$k?HBNE*@\6a(B

$B8D?M$OB>?M$K$h$C$F?HBNE*$K@\6a$5$l$k$H%W%i%$%P%7!<$rAS<:$9$k!#?HBNE*@\6a$H$O!"Nc$($P!"(BY$B$,DL>o$N463P$N;HMQ$K$h$C$F(BX$B$K?($l$?$j4Q;!$7$?$j$9$k$N$K==J,6a$/$K$$$k$3$H$G$"$k!#$?$@$7!"EpD0$K$h$C$FN%$l$?$H$3$m$+$i$G$b(BX$B$r4Q;!$9$k$3$H$O2DG=$@$,!"$3$l$O>pJs$NLdBj$G$"$C$F!"?HBNE*@\6a$NLdBj$G$O$J$$!#(B

$B?HBNE*@\6a$K$h$k%W%i%$%P%7!l9g!"0l?MIt20$N%*%U%#%9$+$iF1N=$,Bg@*$$$kBg$-$J%*%U%#%9$K0\$k>l9g$J$I$,$"$k!#$I$N>l9g$K$*$$$F$b!"IT2w46$NK\pJs$dCmL\$G$O$J$/!"0l?M$G$$$i$l$k6u4V$N>C<:$G$"$k!#(B

$B%W%i%$%P%7!<$O2?$G$J$$$+(B

  1. $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$O!"!VJ|$C$F$*$/$3$H!W$G$O$J$$!#!V?M$rJ|$C$F$*$+$J$$$3$H!W$NBgH>$N;vNc(B($BG<@G!"73Lr!";&?M:a$f$($N=hH3(B)$B$O!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$N?/32$H$O5-=R$7$,$?$$!#$3$l$G$O%W%i%$%P%7!<35G0$NH=L@@-$K7g$1$k!#(B
  2. $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$NAS<:$O?M4V$NB:87$N?/HH$G$O$J$$!#Nc$($P!"@8$-;D$k$?$a$KBN$rGd$k$3$H$O!"B:87$r=}$D$1$i$l$k$+$b$7$l$J$$$,!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$rAS<:$9$k$o$1$G$O$J$$!#(B
  3. $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$O8D?ME*7hDj$KBP$9$k@/I\$NIT43>D$@$H9M$($k$3$H$b$G$-$J$$!#%W%i%$%P%7!<$K4X$9$kMW5a$O!"$`$7$m!"8D?M$KBP$9$kK!E*J]8n$H$$$&7A$G$N@/I\$N43>D$X$NMW5a$@$+$i$G$"$k!#$^$?!"!V@5Ev$JK!D$rMW5a$9$k$3$H$O!"K!E*7hDj$N@-D$NLdBj$O!"$`$7$m!V9T0Y$N<+M3!W$H$$$&LdBj$G$"$k!#(B

$B%W%i%$%P%7!<$N=t5!G=(B($B2ACM$NLdBj(B)

$B$^$:!"40A4$J$k%W%i%$%P%7!<$H$=$NA4LLE*$JAS<:$O$H$b$KK>$^$7$/$J$$!"$H$$$&L@Gr$J;v

$B$?$@$7!"$3$NJ}K!$O%W%i%$%P%7!<$r2?$i$+$NB>$NL\E*$N$?$a$N$NL\E*$H$N7k$S$D$-$NEY9g$$$d!"$=$NL\E*$NK>$^$7$5$K1~$8$F!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$N2ACM$,:81&$5$l$k$3$H$K$J$k!#(B

$B$5$F!"8=:_$N%W%i%$%P%7!

(1)$B$"$k$H$3$m$G$O!"3'IT==J,$JNL$N%W%i%$%P%7!<$7$+;}$C$F$$$J$$798~$,$"$k!#(B($B8D?M$d!"5v$5$l$k$Y$-9T0Y$N

(2)$B%W%i%$%P%7!<$,J?Ey$KG[J,$5$l$F$$$J$$$N$G!">pJsA`:n$d:>5=$J$I!"<+N'$HL1

$B%W%i%$%P%7!<$H8D?M(B

  1. [$B8D@-$NH/E8(B] $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$K$h$C$F!"8D?M$O<+J,<+?H$N9M$(J}$d46$8J}$rB>?M$N$=$l$H6hJL$9$k$h$&$K$J$j!"8D@-$NH/E8$,2DG=$K$J$k!#(B
  2. [$B?HBNE*@\6a$+$i$N<+M3(B] $B?M$O!"?HBNE*@\6a$rpJs3MF@$NB>!"@:?@E*G=NO$dF;FAH=CG$NH/E8$KLrN)$D!#$^$?!"?HBNE*@\6a$N@)8B$K$h$j!"?M$O%j%i%C%/%9$G$-$k$h$&$K$J$k!#$3$l$O@:?@1R@8>e$h$$$3$H$G$"$k!#$5$i$K!"$3$N@)8B$O?F8r$r2DG=$K$9$k!#%j%i%C%/%9$H?F8r$O$H$b$K?M4V4X78$NK\ [$B9T0Y$N<+M3$NB%?J(B] $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$K$h$C$F!"8D?M$N9TF0$OB>?M$N$=$N9TF0$K4X$9$kCN<1$+$i@Z$jN%$5$l!"$=$l$K1~$8$F9T0Y$N<+M3$,B%?J$5$l$k!#Nc$($P!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$,$J$1$l$P!"L$40@.$G [$B<+N'$NB%?J(B] $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$K$h$C$F!"8D?M$O<+J,$N8+2r$r;}$D$3$H$,$G$-$k!# [$B?M4V4X78$NB%?J(B] $B$?$H$(!"AjH?$9$k9M$(J}$d46@-$r;}$C$F$$$?$H$7$F$b!"$=$l$r

    $B$3$N$h$&$K%W%i%$%P%7!<$O<+M3$rB%?J$9$k$H$O$$$(!"$=$l$K$h$C$F0B0W$KLdBj$,1#$5$l$F$7$^$&$3$H$OK>$^$7$/$J$$!#$@$,!"2f!9$O!"8D?M$,;}$D$Y$-<+M3$NHO0O$rH=CG$7!"<+J,$?$A$NMxB>@-$d9gM}@-$N8B3&$r$h$/M}2r$7$?>e$G!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$N5!G=$rG'$a$F$$$k$N$G$"$k!#(B

    $BNc$($P!"$"$k8D?M$,!"B>?M$K7y$o$l$k$H<+J,$G;W$&$h$&$JFCD'(B($BF1@-0&u672<$G$O=EMW$G$J$$!"$HA[Dj$7$h$&!#2f!9$O$=$&$7$?FCD'$r1#$7$?$$$H$$$&H`$NK>$_$r;Y;}$9$Y$-$J$N$+!#$b$7!"2f!9$,JP8+$K$^$C$?$/<|$o$l$:$K$$$i$l$k$N$J$i$P!"1#$9$Y$-$G$O$J$$$@$m$&!#$7$+$7!"o!9<+J,<+?H$NItJ,E*$J5-=R$rM?$($F$$$k$@$1$G$"$j!"C/$b$=$l0J>e$r4|BT$7$F$$$J$$!#LdBj$O!"2f!9$,JT=8$9$Y$-$+H]$+$G$O$J$/!"$$$+$K$7$F!"$=$7$FC/$K$h$C$FJT=8$,9T$o$l$k$+!"$G$"$k!#(B

    $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$H

    $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$O!"$h$jB?85E*$G42MF$J

    $B$^$?!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$O!"L1)$9$k$N$@$+$i!"L1

    $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$NK!E*J]8n(B

    $BK!$N8B3&(B

    $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$NK!E*J]8n$O>o$K$R$I$/@)8B$5$l$F$$$k!#%W%i%$%P%7!<$K4X$9$kH=7h$O!"2f!9$NY$r5/$3$5$J$$>l9g$,B?$$$3$H$G$"$k!#$3$N$3$H$O!"(B(1) $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$N?/32$OK!$K$h$C$F$OJ]8n$5$l$J$$$H$$$&M=B,!"(B(2) $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$N?/32$NB?$/$OHo32Y$r5/$3$9$3$H<+BN$,$5$i$J$k%W%i%$%P%7!<$NAS<:$r$b$?$i$9$3$H$K$J$k$?$a!"K!E*$J2r7h$OE,@Z$G$O$J$$$H$$$&463P!"$3$l$i(B3$B$D$NE@$G@bL@$5$l$k!#$3$&$7$?AJ>Y$N:$Fq$rM}2r$9$k$J$i$P!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$rL5MQ$H9M$($k$h$&$J8m2r$rHr$1$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#$^$?!"B>$N=EMW$JMx1W(B($BI=8=$N<+M3!"A\::$N<+M3(Betc...)$B$,%W%i%$%P%7!<$h$j$bM%@h$5$l$k$3$H$,$"$k!#$3$l$O!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$NK!E*J]8n$N

    (1)$B%W%i%$%P%7!

    (2) $BEv;vo!"<+J,$N;}$AJ*$,Ep$^$l$?$j7@Ls5AL3$,GK4~$5$l$?$j$9$k$h$&$JJ*M}E*$J?/32$,$$$D5/$3$k$N$+$O$o$+$C$F$b!"$$$D2qOC$,K5

    (3) $B8x3+$K$h$i$J$$?/32$N>l9g!"AJ>Y$9$k$3$H$G$5$i$K%W%i%$%P%7!<$rAS<:$7$F$7$^$&!#$9$J$o$A!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$NAS<:$rAJ$($F$*$-$J$,$i!"$=$NAJ>Y9T0Y$K$h$C$F!"1#$=$&$H$7$F$$$?Ev$N>pJs$,8x3+$5$l$F$7$^$&!#(B

    $B0J>e$NMW0x$f$($K%W%i%$%P%7!<$NK!E*J]8n$O:$Fq$J$N$G$"$k!#$3$N:$Fq$O6vA3$G$bWs0UE*$J$b$N$G$b$J$$!#$3$l$OK!$N8zNO$N8B3&$G$"$C$F!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$NMW5a$,ITL@3N$G$"$k$3$H$r0UL#$7$F$$$J$$!#(B

    $B4T85

    $B4T85'$($k$?$a$K!"K!$,%W%i%$%P%7!<$rL@<(E*$K;Y;}(B(explicit commitment)$B$9$Y$-$@$HO@$8$k!#(B

    $BH=Nc

    $B!V%W%i%$%P%7!<$K4X$9$kK!!W$N9M;!$N;EJ}$K$OFsDL$j$"$k!#%W%i%$%P%7!<$H$O2?$+!"K!$O$=$l$r$I$NDxEYJ]8n$9$k$N$+!"$H$$$C$?Ld$$$+$i8=:_$NK!E*J]8n$N4Q$+$i%W%i%$%P%7!<$X$H%"%W%m!<%A$9$k$d$jJ}$G$"$k!#4T85l$O!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$N35G0$rL@<(E*$KF3F~$7$?H=Nc$9$Y$F$r@bL@$7$h$&$H$9$kE@$GM%$l$F$$$k!#(B

    $B$5$F!"H=7h$+$iF@$i$l$?35G0$,0l4S$7$F$$$k(B(coherent)$BJ]>c$O$J$$$7!"!AJH=7h$rMQ$$$F8=9TK!$r5-=R$7$h$&$H$9$k!#(B

    $BLdBjE@(B1$B!'(B $B4T85

    $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$,MW5a$5$l$kB?$/$NH=Nc$K$O%W%i%$%P%7!<$NAS<:$,4^$^$l$F$$$k!#%W%i%$%P%7!<$NH=Nc$KB?$/$N6&DLE@$,B8:_$7$F$$$k$N$O!"$3$N!V%W%i%$%P%7!<$NAS<:!W$N$;$$$G$"$k!#4T85$N2<$K

    $BLdBjE@(B2$B!'(B $B4T85Y$N:$Fq$5$r9MN8$7$F$$$J$$!#(B

    $B4T85Y$@$1$r07$$!"!AJ$,J]>c$5$l$?H=Nc$r:N$j>e$2$F$$$k$,!"$3$l$O%W%i%$%P%7!<$K4X$7$F$O%_%9%j!<%G%#%s%0$G$"$k!#%W%i%$%P%7!<$K4X$9$kAJ>Y$O!"4{$K8+$?M}M3(B(3-1)$B$+$i!"5/$3$j$K$/$$$N$G$"$k!#(B

    $BK!E*$G$J$$%W%i%$%P%7!<$N35G0$+$i=PH/$9$k$3$H$G!"$3$&$7$?Mn$H$77j$rHr$1$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#$^$?!"$3$N%"%W%m!<%A$K$h$C$F!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$H$$$&0l4S$7$?2ACM$NK!E*J]8n$r$9$Y$FpJs3+<(!"Z8@5qH]8"$NGX8e$K$"$kM}M3!"<+8JIi:a5qH]8"!"0cK!<}=8>Z5rGS=|$N86B'$J$I$,9MN8$5$l$k!#B>J}!"L@<(E*$K%W%i%$%P%7!<$r;Y;}$7$F$$$F$b%_%9%j!<%G%#%s%0$J;EJ}$G%W%i%$%P%7!<35G0$rF3F~$7$F$$$k;vNc(B($B$"$kD$NLH=|$NMW5a(Betc...)$B$O=|$+$l$k!#(B

    $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$NNr;KE*2r

    $B4T85k$G$"$k!W$H$$$&86B'$,$"$k$7!"@/I\Lr?M$,;}$DA\::8"$N@)8B$dHkL)$K4X$9$k873J$J5,HO!"$N$>$-$N6X;_$J$I$,Aa$/$+$iB8:_$7$F$$$?!#$7$?$,$C$F!"8=Be$N%W%i%$%P%7!<$K4X$9$kK!E*J]8n$NMW@A$b$=$N1dD9$H$7$FB*$($k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#$3$&$7$?;~4VE*$JO"B3@-$K5$$E$/$3$H$G!"2f!9$O!"

    $B3N$+$K!"%W%i%$%P%7!]$G$"$k!#$@$,!"$=$NM}M3$r?M4V$N463P$d0U<1$NJQ2=$K5a$a$kI,MW$O$J$$!#$H$$$&$N$b!"8=Be$N?M4V$NJ}$,@N$N?M4V$h$j$b463P$d0U<1$NE@$G?JJb$7$F$$$k$H$O8@$($J$$$+$i$G$"$k!#(B

    $B$3$N4X?4$N9b$^$j$N/$J$/$H$bItJ,E*$K5/0x$9$k!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$KBP$9$k6<0R$NpJs$N5-O?!&<}G@-$NAS<:$K$h$C$F>]D'$5$l$k!#$b$O$d%f%4!<$d%7%'!<%/%9%T%"$NIA$/$h$&$J!"JQAu$7$F;|A1$r;\$9Gn0&?4$"$U$l$k0N?M$OB8:_$G$-$J$$!#(B

    $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$NF?L>@-$H$$$&B&LL$K4X$9$kAJ>Y$O8=BeE*$G$"$k$,!"?HBNE*$J@\6a$K4X$9$kAJ>Y$O?7$?$K5/$3$C$F$$$J$$$3$H$+$i!"?HBNE*$J@\6a$K$D$$$F$O8=Be$G$bBg$-$JJQ2=$O$J$$$3$H$,$o$+$k!#$3$l$O!"%F%/%N%m%8!<$NH/C#$,8=BeE*$J%W%i%$%P%7!<$KBP$9$k4X?4$NZ$7$F$$$k!#$^$?!"D4::$r@86H$H$9$k?M8}$NA}2C!"8x3+2DG=$J>pJs$rC5$93hF0$N9b$^$j!"$=$&$7$?;n$_$r2DG=$K$9$kAuCV$N?JJb$J$I$b>pJs$d=PMh;v$N5-O?!&8x3+$N798~$r=uD9$7$F$$$k!#(B

    $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$X$NL@<(E*$J;Y;}(B

    $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$NK!E*J]8n$O!"B>$N!V$h$jB:=E$9$Y$-!W2ACM$NJ]8n$NC1$J$kI{;:J*$K$H$I$^$i$J$$!#%W%i%$%P%7!<$X$NL@<(E*$J;Y;}$K$h$C$F!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$NAS<:$,!">/$J$/$H$b4{$K<($7$?L\E*$d5!G=(B(2-1$B!"(B2)$B$rB;$J$o$;$k>u672<$G$OK>$^$7$/$J$$!"$H$$$&$3$H$,L@$i$+$K$J$k!#(B

    $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$,L@<(E*$K;Y;}$5$l$k$N$O!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$,2f!9$N

    $BH?O@(B1$B!'(B $B%"%a%j%+$NK!BN7O$O$9$G$K%W%i%$%P%7!<$r;Y;}$7$F$*$j!"2f!9$O!"$9$G$K$J$5$l$?;Y;}$rD9!9$HO@$8$k$h$j!"$`$7$mK!E*J]8n$N

    $B$7$+$7!"

    $BH?O@(B2$B!'(B $B2f!9$O$9$G$KI,MW$J$@$1$N%W%i%$%P%7!<$rM-$7$F$$$k$N$@$+$i!"$3$l0J>e$NK!E*J]8n$OITMW$G$"$j!"$=$l$f$(!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$r;Y;}$9$k$Y$-$G$O$J$$!#(B

    $B$3$N5DO@$K$h$l$P!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$N?/32$,K>$^$7$/$J$$$H$5$l$kNN0h$G$OK!$O$9$G$K$3$l$rJ]8n$7$F$*$j!"$=$NB>$N?/32$,$"$k$K$;$h!"$+$D$F$h$j$bB?$/$N%W%i%$%P%7!<$r5|e$7$F$$$k$N$@$+$i!":#0J>e$NK!E*J]8n$OITMW$@$H$$$&$3$H$K$J$k!#(B

    $B$7$+$7!"%W%i%$%P%7!<5|@-!"$D$^$j!"C/$N4X?4$NBP>]$K$b$J$i$J$$$3$H$G$"$k!#$7$?$,$C$F!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$,J]8n$5$l$k$N$O!"?/32$NFq$7$5$K$h$k$N$G$O$J$/!"?/32$7$h$&$H$9$kF05!$HB>?M$N4X?4$H$N7gG!$K$h$k$N$G$"$k!#$7$?$,$C$F!"?M!9$,%W%i%$%P%7!<$r?/32$7$h$&$H;W$o$J$$$3$H$,I,MW$J$N$G$"$k!#(B

    $B%W%i%$%P%7!<$X$NL@<(E*$J;Y;}$K$h$C$F!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$NAS<:$KBP$9$k8D!9?M$N46pJs$NO31H$rKI$0EXNO$,B%$5$l$?$j$9$k2DG=@-$,$"$k!#:G$b=EMW$JE@$O!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$X$NL@<(E*$J;Y;}$,650iE*$J8z2L$r;}$D$H$$$&$3$H$G$"$k!#K!E*J]8n$NI,MW$J$7$K%W%i%$%P%7!<$r5|o$K=EMW$J$N$G$"$k!#K!$NCf$G$O$C$-$j$H!V%W%i%$%P%7!<$OCf?4E*$J2ACM$G$"$k!W$H8@L@$5$l$l$P!"%W%i%$%P%7!<$N=EMW$J5!G=$,$$$C$=$&<+3P$5$l$k$3$H$K$J$k$@$m$&!#(B

    ($B1|EDB@O:(B)

    1 Ruth Gavison, "Privacy and the Limits of Law" in The Yale Law Journal, Vol. 89, No. 3, January 1980, pp. 421-471.

    2$B$3$l$O!"%3%s%T%e!<%?$K$h$k%G!<%?8!:w$K$D$$$F$b8@$($k$3$H$G$"$k!#8D!9$N>pJs$OCGJRE*$G0lHLE*$J$b$N$G$"$j$J$,$i!"$"$k%-!<%o!<%I$rDL$8$F>pJs$,E}9g$5$l$k$3$H$K$h$j!"$4$/8D?ME*$J>pJs$KJQ2=$9$k$3$H$,$"$k!#(B

    3$B%3%s%T%e!<%?%M%C%H%o!<%/$K$h$C$F!"3H;6$OMF0W$K9T$($k$h$&$K$J$C$?!#(B

    $BL\

    Last modified: Wed Jan 12 16:55:21 JST 2000