$B;d$OM'C#$K%=%U%H%&%'%"$r%3%T!<$9$Y$-$+(B?1

$B%X%l%s!&%K%C%;%s%P%&%`(B

$B%-!<%o!<%I(B

1. $BO@J8$N35MW(B

$B$3$NO@J8$NL\E*(B

$B!X%3%T!<6X;_$N6/$$N)>l!Y$rH?G}$9$k$3$H!#$3$NN)>l$Oo$KIT@5(B(always wrong)$B$G$"$k!#!W$3$NA4>NL?Bj$rH?G}$9$k$3$H$,L\E*$G$"$k$N$G!"5DO@$NBP>]$H$J$k>u67$,Hs>o$K8BDj$5$l$F$$$k!#(B

$B@_Dj$5$l$F$$$k>u67(B

$B!V<+BDMn$JM'?M$N@83h$r=u$1$k(B($B2~A1$9$k(B)$B$?$a$K!"<+J,$N=jM-$9$k2H7WJm%=%U%H%&%'%"$N%3%T!<$rM'?M$KDs6!$9$k$3$H$O5v$5$l$k$+(B?$B!W$3$N>u67$OL58"8B%3%T!<0lHL$N@'Hs$,Ld$o$l$k>l9g$KHf$Y$FHs>o$K6/$$@)8B$r;}$C$F$$$k!#@0M}$9$l$P!"(B(1)$B;dE*$J?M4V4X78$NHO0OFb$G(B(2)$BHs1DMxE*$K$J$5$l$k8BDj$5$l$?NL$NL58"8B%3%T!<$N@'Hs$,O@$8$i$l$F$$$k$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B5DO@>e$NA0Ds(B

$B$5$i$KCxe$NLdBj$K4X$7$F$J$5$l$F$*$j!"K!N'>e$NLdBj$O$[$H$s$I(B($B8N0U$K(B)$BL5;k$5$l$F$$$k!#$^$?!"5DO@$N4JN,2=$N$?$a!"%=%U%H%&%'%"@=:nDj$5$l$F$$$k!#(B

$BCx

$B!V$d$`$K$d$^$l$LM}M3$H$$$&$b$N$,$"$j!"L58"8B%3%T!<$,F;FA86M}$N?/32$H$O$J$i$J$$>l9g$,B8:_$9$k!W$N$G$"$C$F!"!V!X%3%T!<6X;_$N6/$$N)>l!Y$O%=%U%H%&%'%"@=:ne$NMW5a$HMx1W$r6/D4$9$k$"$^$j!"$=$l0J30$N4X78l!Y$OF;FA86M}$H$7$FIaJWE*$K$O@.$jN)$?$J$$$N$G$"$C$F!"8D!9$N>l9g$r6hJL$9$k$3$H$,I,MW$H$J$k!#!W$H$$$&$N$,Cx

$B5DO@$NAH$_N)$F(B

$B!V>e$Nl!YMJ8n$N5DO@$r$=$l$>$l8!F$$7!"!X%3%T!<6X;_$N6/$$N)>l!Y$,IaJWE*$K$OMJ8n$7$($J$$$3$H$r3NG'$9$k!W$H=xJ8$G=R$Y$i$l$F$$$k!#$7$+$7@\E*$K>e$N

2. $B5"7kl!YMJ8n$N5DO@$N8!F$(B

$B5"7k

$BCxl!YMJ8n$N5DO@$r

$BL58"8B%3%T!<$,F;FAE*$KIT@5$J$N$O!">/$J$/$H$bD94|E*$+$D9-HO$J1F6A$H$$$&0UL#$G$O!"9%$^$7$/$J$$5"7k$r>CHqJ}$K$b$?$i$9$+$i$G$"$k!#9%$^$7$/$J$$5"7k$H$O!"%=%U%H%&%'%"$KBP$9$kA4BNE*$J;Y=P$NL\8:$j$K$h$k(B(1)$B@):n$X$NM60x$NDc2e>:!"$G$"$k!#$3$l$i$O6&$K8x6&$NJ!;c$rDc2<$5$;$k$3$H$K$J$k!#(B

$B$3$N5DO@$X$NH?O@(B

$B5"7ke$N5DO@$O!"

$B!VL58"8B%3%T!/!W$7!"!V%=%U%H%&%'%"@=:n/!W$9$k$?$a!"!V%=%U%H%&%'%"3+H/$X$NM60x$,Dc27$-!":G=*E*$K$O$=$l$,!V8x6&$NJ!;c$NAm9gE*$JDc2

$B$3$N!VIw$,?a$1$P2320$,$b$&$+$k!W<0$N%b%G%k$O0lL\$GM}2r$7$d$9$/!"$^$?0lDj$N@bF@NO$r;}$C$F$$$k$h$&$K;W$o$l$k!#$7$+$7$J$,$i!"$=$l$>$l$NMWAG4V$KA[Dj$5$l$F$$$kAj4X4X78$OK\Ev$K3N$+(B($BD>@\E*(B)$B$J$N$@$m$&$+(B?$B$3$N$h$&$JJ,$+$j0W2a$.$k%b%G%k$KBP$7$F5?Ld$r;}$D$3$H$O@5Ev$G$"$k!#$3$3$G$NCxl9g$HF1MM$K!"F;FA$K4X$9$k5DO@$H$7$F$3$N5DO@$rE,MQ$9$k$?$a$K$O!"$-$A$s$H$3$NAj4X4X78$rN)>Z$9$k@UG$$,5"7kZ$G$-$?$H$7$F$b!"!VL58"8B%3%T!Z$G$-$J$$8B$j$O!"L58"8B%3%T!<$N6X;_$OF;FAE*$K$O@5Ev2=$G$-$J$$!#$=$7$F!"$=$N$h$&$JAj4X4X78$ON)>Z$G$-$J$$!#(B

$BCx@\E*$K$O@.$jN)$?$J$$$3$H$r<($=$&$H$7$F=R$Y$F$$$kFbMF$r

$B!VL58"8B%3%T!/!W(B

$B$3$N4V$NAj4X4X78$rO@$8$k$K:]$7$F!"5"7kDj$7$F$$$k!#$D$^$j!"!V(B($B$=$N@=IJ$r(B)$BGc$&!W$+!"!V%3%T!<$9$k!W$+!"$NHf3S$G$"$k!#$7$+$7!"$3$N2>Dj$O8m$j$G$"$k!#$J$<$J$i!"MxMQ$K$b$C$HM_$7$$$b$N$,$"$k$H$$$C$?M}M3$+$i$G$"$k!#$@$+$iMxMQ/$9$k$3$H$O$[$H$s$IL5$$!#$`$7$m!"0lHLE*MxMQ

$B!V%=%U%H%&%'%"@=:n/!W"*!V%=%U%H%&%'%"3+H/$X$NM60x$,Dc2

$B3N$+$K!"Hs>o$K<}F~$,8:$l$P$=$&$J$k$G$"$m$&!#$7$+$7!"<}F~$N$o$:$+$J8:>/$,%=%U%H%&%'%"3+H/$X$NM60x$KBP$7$F;}$D8z2L$OL@$i$+$G$O$J$$!#%j%A%c!<%I!&%9%H!<%k%^%s(B2$B$,=R$Y$k$h$&$K!"9b$$%b%A%t%'!<%7%g%s$r;}$D%=%U%H%&%'%"@=:n

$B!VL58"8B%3%T!

$B%j%A%c!<%I!&%9%H!<%k%^%s$O8yMx$N%3%s%T%e!<%?%3!<%I$N<+M3$JJ,G[$N@)8B$K$h$C$F%3%s%T%e!<%?%F%/%N%m%8!<$N?JE8$,CY$l$k!"$H$$$&$N$G$"$k!#$+$D$F$N%3!<%I$d%"%$%G%"$N<+M3$J8r49$3$=$,6C$/$Y$-B.EY$NH/E8$r;:$_=P$7$?$N$G$"$k!#$=$l$,:#$d!"$=$l$i$r@)8B$9$kK!$,K!E*$K5pBg$J1F6ANO$H8"NO$H$r;}$C$?J]&6HE*$K9XF~2DG=$J%=%U%H%&%'%"$,A}Bg$7$?$H$7$F$b!"$=$NA}Bg$O!"%F%/%N%m%8!<$N@h?JE*$JItJ,$N<:B.$r$b>7$/$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B!VL58"8B%3%T!

$B8x6&$NJ!;c$KBP$9$kL58"8B%3%T!<$N1F6A$O$I$&$$$&$b$N$+!"$H$$$&IaJWE*$JLdBj$N%l%Y%k$K$*$$$F$O!"%=%U%H%&%'%"$HJ!;c$N4V$KM-0U$J4X78$r0z$-$@$9$3$H$O$*$=$i$/IT2DG=$G$"$k!#@x:_E*$JL58"8B%3%T!<l!Y$O!"D>@\E*$JB;<:$rKd$a9g$o$;$k$b$N$,$[$H$s$IL5$$$H$$$&$3$H$rMQ$$$:$K!"%3%T!<$r:9$795$($k$3$H$NL@Gr$Ju67$@$1$K$G$O$J$/!"%3%T!<$5$l$k%=%U%H%&%'%"$N

$B$^$?!"L58"8B%3%T!<$K$h$kB;<:$,B8:_$9$k$+$.$j!"$=$NJ,$rNA6b$KH?1G$5$;$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$/$J$k$H$$$&5DO@$KBP$7$F$O!"$b$7$b85!9NA6b$,

$B$3$N5DO@$N$^$H$a(B

$B$3$3$^$G$N5DO@$N$^$H$a$H$7$F$B!VB?MM$J>CHqe$N

$B$=$NM}M3$H$7$F$O!"$^$:Bh0l$K!"5"7kl!Y$,4p$E$/7P83CO$,$"$k!"$H$$$&$3$H$,5s$2$i$l$F$$$k!#$5$i$K$$$($P!"5"7kl9g$H$G$O!"$=$l$,;:$_=P$91F6A$OA4$/0{$J$c$?$b$N$H$J$k$@$m$&!#(B

$BBhFs$K!"!X%3%T!<6X;_$N6/$$N)>l!Y$O!"8D?ME*$J%(%s%I%f!<%6!<$K%=%U%H%&%'%"6H3&$N7rA4$5$r0];}$9$k$?$a$NIiC4$r$+$1$F$$$k!#$3$l$O!"8D?ME*$J%f!<%6!<$KBP$9$kIT9gM}$J@UG$$N=8Cf$G$"$k!#$?$H$($P!"%=%U%H%&%'%"$,<+e$2$K7hDjE*$K9W8%$9$k$H$o$+$C$F$$$k$J$i!"%O!<%I%a!<%+!<$O$=$N%=%U%H%&%'%"$r;Y1g$9$k$3$H$r(B($B40A4$K9gM}E*$K(B)$B7hCG$9$k$+$b$7$l$J$$!#$5$i$K!"%=%U%H%&%'%"$=$l<+BN0J30$K$b%=%U%H%&%'%"@=IJ$K$OIU2CE*$J%5!<%S%9(B($B$?$H$($P!"%f!<%6!<%5%]!<%H$d!"%^%K%e%"%k$d!"%=%U%H%&%'%"$N%"%C%W%G!<%H!"Ey(B)$B$,4^$^$l$k$N$G!"%=%U%H%a!<%+!<$O$3$l$i$N%5!<%t%#%9$K$h$C$FGc$&$3$H$KBP$9$k%$%s%;%s%F%#%t$r%f!<%6!<$KM?$($F$$$k$N$G$"$k!#?=$7N)$F$i$l$?L58"8B%3%T!<$K$b$+$+$o$i$:!"M%$l$?@=IJ$H%^!<%1%F%#%s%0$N@.2L$N>Z$H$7$F!"B?$/$N1I$($F$$$k%=%U%H%a!<%+!<$,@.N)$7$F$$$k!#%=%U%H%&%'%";:6H$K1F6A$rM?$($k$N$O8D?ME*$J%(%s%I%f!<%6!<$@$1$G$O$J$$$N$G$"$k!#$f$($K!"8D?ME*$J%(%s%I%f!<%6!<$K$N$_IT8xJ?$J@UG$$rIiC4$5$;$h$&$H$9$k$N$O!"IT@5$J$3$H$G$"$k!#(B

3. $B8"MxO@$K$h$k!X%3%T!<6X;_$N6/$$N)>l!YMJ8n$N5DO@$N8!F$(B

$B8"MxO@$K$h$l$P!"L58"8B%3%T!<$O%W%m%0%i%^!<$NF;FAE*8"Mx$N?/32$G$"$j!"!VH`$i$NO+F/$rB:=E$9$k!W$H$$$&F;FAE*5AL3$rBU$k$3$H$G$"$k!#$^$?!"$3$N5AL3$O@dBPE*$J$b$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B$3$N5DO@$X$NH?O@(B

$BCxl9g$N8"Mx$H$O2?$G$"$k$+!"(B(2)$Bl9g!"%W%m%0%i%^!<$K$A$KA4$F$NL58"8B%3%T!<$,8"Mx?/32$G$"$k$H$$$&$3$H$K$O$J$i$J$$!#$5$i$K!"(B(3)$B%W%m%0%i%`$KBP$9$k:b;:8"$,L58"8B%3%T!<$r@)8B$r2C$($k8"Mx$r4^$`$3$H$,<($5$l$M$P$J$i$J$$$,!"$3$l$OL@$i$+$G$"$k$H$O$$$($J$$!#$=$l$K$b94$i$:!"B?$/$N8"MxO@

$B%=%U%H%&%'%"$r=jM-$9$k$3$H$HL58"8B%3%T!<$r6X;_$9$k$3$H$OI,A3E*$J$D$J$,$j$r;}$D$+(B

$B=jM-$N>r7o$rDj$a$k8"Mx$rM?$($k$b$N!#(B)$B$3$N=t8"Mx$N=89g$H$$$&IaJWE*$J4QG0$+$i(B(1)$BMN8=Bee3XE*@-$C$FL@3N$KFCDj$5$l$?8"Mx$N=89g$,CHq$9$k8"Mx$d!"Fs$D$K3d$C$FM'C#$HJ,$1$k$+$I$&$+$r7hDj$9$k8"MxEy$,!#$@$,!"$3$N$h$&$J8"Mx$O!"EZCO=jM-l9g$K$O0UL#$r$J$5$J$$!#(B)$B=>$C$F!"CNE*:b;:$O=jM-$NEAE}E*35G0$r3HD%$9$k$3$H$K$J$k$,!"%=%U%H%&%'%"$r=jM-$9$k$H$$$&$3$H$N0UL#$,$$$+$J$k$b$N$G$"$k$+$H$$$&LdBj$,$"$k!#Hf3SE*C1=c$J%W%m%0%i%`$G$5$(B??t$N9=@.MWAG$H$5$^$6$^$JB&LL$+$i@.$jN)$C$F$$$k!#$=$l$f$(!"%W%m%0%i%`$H$$$&!XJ*!Y$rDj5A$9$k!"$^$?;dE*=jM-$NBP>]$H$J$k$b$N$r3NDj$9$k!"$H$$$&$3$H$,LdBj$H$J$k!#%W%m%0%i%`$rF1Dj$9$ke3XE*@-]$G$"$k!"$H9M$($i$l$k$3$H$,$"$k!#$3$3$G$N;vNc$G$O!"%3%T!<$5$l$F$$$k$N$OL@$i$+$K%*%V%8%'%/%H%3!<%I$G$"$k$+$i!"%=%U%H%&%'%"$r=jM-$9$k$H$$$&$3$H$N0UL#$,$$$+$J$k$b$N$G$"$k$+$H$$$&LdBj$O!"$3$N;vNc$N$$r9M$($k$J$i2sHr$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#(B($B$7$+$7$J$,$i!"%W%m%0%i%`$N$3$&$$$C$?7A<)>e3XE*@-

$B0J>e$N5DO@$rF'$^$($?$&$($G!"%W%m%0%i%`$KBP$7$F=jM-8"$r;}$D$H$$$&;ve3XE*@-$C$F!"%W%m%0%i%^!<$O9%$-$JCMCJ$G%W%m%0%i%`$rJ#@=$7$?%G%#%9%/$rHNGd$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#$@$,!"HNGd$7$?8e$b%W%m%0%i%`$=$l<+BN$r=jM-$7$F$$$k$N$@$+$i!"%W%m%0%i%^!<$OL58"8B%3%T!<$r6X;_$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#$3$l$,:b;:$NMxMQ$r@)8B$9$k8"Mx$+$iL58"8B%3%T!<$N6X;_$r0z$-$@$95DO@$G$"$j!"

$B$7$+$7!"$3$N5DO@$O=jM-8"M}O@$N=EMW$J9=@.MWAG$r$N8"Mx$HF1MM$K!"=jM-8"$bB>l9g!"=jM-

$B$=$7$F!"$3$N$3$H$O%=%U%H%&%'%"$N>l9g$K$bE,MQ$5$l$k!#Cx

$B$3$NO@J8$GA[Dj$5$l$F$$$k;vNc$G9M$($F$_$h$&!#:$$C$F$$$kM'?M$N$?$a$K%3%T!<$9$k$H$$$&$3$H$OBP93E*$+$DBEEv$JMW5a$J$N$G$"$m$&$+(B?$BL@$i$+$K!"L58"8B%3%T!<$K$h$C$F%W%m%0%i%^!<$NMx1W$H6%9g$9$k$h$&$JL\E*$r;}$C$F$$$k$o$1$G$O$J$$!#$J$<$J$i!"L5@)8B$KBgNL$NL58"8B%3%T!<$r9T$&0U?^$J$IL5$$$+$i$G$"$k!#$3$N>l9g$O!"C1$K:$$C$F$$$kM'?M$K?F@Z$K$7$?$$$H$$$&!";dE*$G69$$NN0h$G$NH~FA$rDI5a$9$k<+M3$rMW5a$7$F$$$k$@$1$G$"$k!#$3$N$h$&$J;dE*NN0h$G$N9T0Y$K43>D$9$l$P!"B>

$B$3$N$h$&$K!"0lJ}$K$O%W%m%0%i%^!<$N8"Mx$rB:=E$9$k$H$$$&5AL3$,$"$j!"B>J}$K$OB>WFM$,B8:_$9$k$N$G$"$k!#$h$C$F!"0lJ}$N5AL3$,@dBPE*$G$"$k$H$O$$$($J$$!#(B

$B0J>e$N$h$&$KCx

$B$^$:Bh0l$KM=A[$5$l$k0[5D$H$O!"u67$K$*$$$F$b2?$,F;FAE*(B($B:b;:>e$N(B)$B8"Mx$H$5$l$k$+$Kl9g$KBP$7$F!"=jM-

$B;dE*$JNN0h$K$*$1$k%3%T!<$,F;FAE*$K5v$5$l$k$H$J$l$P!"$3$N$3$H$,0z$-$,$M$H$J$C$FL5@)8B$K%3%T!<$,HEMt$7!"$=$N%3%T!<$,Gd$i$l$k$h$&$K$J$C$F!"%W%m%0%i%^!<$N8"Mx$,40A4$KG'$a$i$l$J$/$J$C$F$7$^$&$+$b$7$l$J$$!#$3$N$h$&$J$$$o$f$k3j$j:dM}O@$K$h$k0[5D$,!"e$K$P$i$^$/$3$H$O!"$?$H$(A10U$K4p$E$$$F$$$?$H$7$F$b!"%W%m%0%i%^!<$N8"Mx$KBP93E*$JMW5a$r7g$$$F$$$k$N$G$"$k!#$3$N$h$&$J8x6&E*$^$?$O>&6HE*$JNN0h$K$*$$$F$O!"K!$d5,@)$r:n$k$3$H$,4|BT$5$l$k$HCx

$BL58"8B%3%T!<$OEp$_$J$N$GITF;FA$J9T0Y$G$"$k!"$H$$$&0[5D$b9M$($i$l$k!#$7$+$7!"$3$N0[5D$NA0Ds$G$"$k!VL58"8B%3%T!<$OEp$_$G$"$k!W$H$$$&$3$H$O==J,$K$O3N>Z$5$l$F$$$J$$$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B$3$N5DO@$N$^$H$a(B

$B$3$3$G$N5DO@$K$h$C$FCx

4. $BA4BN$N7kO@(B

$B!X%3%T!<6X;_$N6/$$N)>l!Y$O!"$=$l$,e$N0lHL@-$r;}$D$3$H$O$J$$!#$b$A$m$s!"A4$F$NL58"8B%3%T!<$,F;FAE*$K5v$5$l$k$H$B!V$b$7!"6a$7$$?M!9$NI,MW$K1~$($h$&$H$$$&<+A3$J:_$jJ}$rL5;k$7$F$7$^$&$3$H$K$h$C$F$N$_%3%T!<$r:,@d$d$7$K$9$k$3$H$,2DG=$H$J$k$N$G$"$l$P!"$o$l$o$l$O7k6I$N$H$3$m4|BT8zMQ$r:GBg2=$7$F$J$$$N$+$b$7$l$J$$!#!W(B

5. $B%3%a%s%H(B

$B$3$NO@J8$K$*$1$kCxe$N%9%H!<%k%^%s$N8@MU$K6E=L$5$l$F$$$k$H;W$o$l$k!#$7$+$7LdBj$O!"H`$i$N8@$&!V6a$7$$?M!9!W$H$O$$$C$?$$C/$r4^$`$N$+!)!"$H$$$&$3$H$K$"$k!#Cxl9g$H5v$5$l$J$$>l9g$H$N6hJL$O!"$=$l$[$I%/%j%"!<$G$O$J$$$h$&$K;W$o$l$k!#(B

$B!J?@:j(B $B@k

1 Helen Nissenbaum "Should I Copy My Neighbor's Software?" in Deborah G. Johnson & Helen Nissenbaum (eds.), Computers, Ethics & Social Values, Prentice Hall, 1995.

2 Richard Stallman$B!#(BFSF(Free Software Foundation)$B$N

$BL\

Last modified: Wed Jan 12 16:58:06 JST 2000