$B$=$l$G$b!";d$r4^$a$?NQM}3X2A$5$lB3$1$F$-$?!"%X%"$K$h$k8yMx$5$l$k$+$K$D$$$F4X?4$r$b$DFI$7$K$"$k$+$i$G$"$k!#(B
1. $B%X%"$NIaJW2=2DG=@-MW7o$O$I$N$h$&$K8+D>$5$l$?$+(B
$BFb0f65$7$O!"0J2<$N$h$&$K$^$H(B
$B$a$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#(B
(1)$BF;FAH=CG$NIaJW2=2DG=@-$H!"!V$9$Y$F$N?M$NA1$rF1Ey$K9MN8$9$k$H$$$&>r(B
$B7o!W(B($BA1$N=E$_$E$1!#$3$l$r!VA1$NIaJW2=2DG=@-!W$H$b$$$&(B)$B$N6hJL!#(B
(2)$BIaJW2=2DG=@-MW7o$OO@M}E*%F!<%<$G$O$J$$$7!"F;FA5/8;O@$N4QE@$+$i$_$F(B
$B$b6/$9$.$k!#(B(17$B@a(B)$BAj8_E*$J5,B'$K$h$C$F8_$$$N9T0Y$r5,@)$9$k$H$$$&>r7o$O(B
$B$"$C$F$b!"$3$l$O!VGSB>@-!w$d8DBN$KBP$9$k8@5Z$rGS=|$7$J$$$b$N$G$"$j!"87(B
$BL)$JIaJW2=2DG=@-$H$O8@$($J$$!#(B
$B$9$Y$F$N?M$NA1$rF1Ey$K9MN8$9$k$H$$$&>r7o$K$D$$$F$b!"F;FA5/8;O@$N4QE@$+$i$$k8B$j!"!V$9$Y$F$N?M!W$,!V?MN`0lHL!W$d!V463P$N$"$k$9$Y$F$NB8:_!W$K$^$G3HD%$G$-$k$H$$$&$3$H$O<+L@$G$O$J$$!#(B
$B0J>e$NJ,@O$K$h$j!"IaJW2=2DG=@-MW7o$H!VA1$NEy$7$$9MN8$N>r7o!W$NAPJ}(B
$B$N87L)$JIaJW2=$rr7o$H$7$F$O6/$9$.$F<+L@(B
$B$H$O$$$($J$$!V9-$$HO0O$K$o$?$kA4$F$NB8:_$NA1$rF1Ey$K9MN8$9$k$H$$$&>r7o!W(B
$B$NAPJ}$r
($B0zMQ(B)$B$3$l$,$"$kDxEY$Nr7o$N@5Ev@-$r8@$&$3$H$O$`$:$+$7$$!#$7$+$7!"$I$N$h$&$J>r7o$N2<$G$=$l(B
$B$N@5Ev@-$,8@$($k$+$,L@$i$+$K$J$l$P!"$3$l$OE/3XE*J,@O$K$*$1$k0l$D$N=EMW(B
$B$J<}3O$H$J$k!#(B(25$B@a(B)
$B$=$N!V@5Ev@-$N>r7o$r=R$Y$k!W;n$_$K$*$$$F!"65
$B8+9~$(B: $BDAj]$H$5$l$k?M!9$NHO0O$r3H(B $BD%$9$k!"$D$^$jAj8_@-$"$k$$$O!VIaJW2=!W$N(B
$B9M;!$r9-$2$k$3$H$K$O!"$=$l$K8+9g$&Mx1W$,(B($B>r7o
$B$3$N8+9~$_$,M-K>$G$"$k$3$H$r<($9$5$$$KFb0f65
(3) $B;34_8&5f(B(26$B@a!A(B28$B@a(B)$B$H!V8BDj$5$l$?9gM}@-!W$K<(:6$rF@$F$N9M;!(B
$BN>$B@-!W$"$k$$$O!V69$$Aj8_@-!W$+$i!V3+$+$l$?Aj8_@-!W$X$H(B
$BH4$1=P$k$3$H(B)$B$,2DG=$K$J$k!#(B
$B$=$N7k2L!"8BDj$5$l$?$b$N$G$"$k$3$H$K$OJQ$o$j$J$$$,!"!V2~A1!W$5$l$?(B
$B9gM}@-$K$O$J$jF@$k!#(B
$B$3$l$O!"(B $B695A$NIaJW2=2DG=@-(B($B@55A$N86M}(B)$B$@$1$G$J$/!"0[$J$k?M!9$N!VA1$NF1Ey$J07$$!W$K$D$$$F$b$"$F$O$^$k!#(B
$B$=$7$F!"A10-$N8D?M4VHf3S$H=E$$E$1$O!"H=CG$9$k?M$N(b(;$b9q$d6&F1BN$j$I$K(B
$BG{$i$l$?(B)$BGSB>E*BVEY$NM-L5$K$h$C$FBg$-$/:81&$5$l$&$k!#(B
$B0J>e$N9M;!$K$h$j!"(B(1)$BIaJW2=2DG=@-MW7o$*$h$S!VA1$NF1Ey$JG[N8!W$NMW7o(B
$B$O%X%"$,=R$Y$F$$$?$h$&$J!VF;FAH=CG$NO@M}E*@-
$B$o$?$7$NM}2r$K$h$l$P!"0J>e$,!"Fb0f65$7!W$G$"$k!#(B
2.$B
$B$H$3$m$G!"0J>e$N$h$&$KIaJW2=2DG=@-MW7o$,8+D>$5$l$k$J$i!"IaJW2=$5$l(B
$B$k$Y$-!VNQM}E*G[N8!W$NHO0O$b8+D>$5$l$k$3$H$K$O$J$i$J$$$N$@$m$&$+!#$R$$(B
$B$F$O!"NQM}E*'$($k%7%s%,!<$i=>Mh$N8yMx
$BIaJW2=2DG=@-$N8+D>$7$K$D$$$F!"Fb0f65
($B0zMQ(B)......$B$b$A$m$s!"$9$Y$F$N?M!9$,IaJW2=2DG=@-$r/$J$/$H$b?M!9$N0lIt$KDjCe(B
$B$7$&$k$3$H!"$^$?!"$o$l$o$l$,CN$k!VF;FA@-!W$K$h$C$FMW5a$5$l$k$h$&$J!"A1(B
$B$N=E$_$E$1$NJQ2=$,F1$8$/9gM}E*$JA*Br$N(B $B7k2L$H$7$F$b$?$i$5$l$&$k$3$H$K(B
$B$9$.$J$$!#$7$+$7!"$=$l$i$N7k2L$,?M!9(B $B$KBP$7$F5,HOE*$J94B+$r$b$?$i$9M}(B
$BM3$O(B---$B9gM}E*A*Br$N4pHW$H$J$C$?A*9%$,?M!9$N9T0Y$r94B+$9$k$N$G$"$k!#$7(B
$B$?$,$C$F!"9gM}@-$rDI5a$7$h$&$H$9$l$P!V0Y$9$Y$-$3$H!W(B $B$O$o$J$$?M!9$,B8:_$9$k$3$H$O4T85$N<:GT$r0UL#$7$J$$!#$=(B
$B$&$$$C$??M!9$,$$$k$+$i$3$=!"!V$Y$7!W$,0UL#$r;}$A!"F;FA$NB8:_M}M3$,$"$k!#(B
(32$B@a(B)
($B0zMQ(B)..........$B?M4V$N$C$FA*Br$5$l$k;EJ}$G$"$k!"(B
$B$H$$$&$N$,8=:_$N$o$?$7$N8+Ev$G$"$k$+$i!"$3$l$OJQ2=$7$&$k$N$G!"0l(B
$B5A@-$r$b$DJ]>Z$O$J$$!#2~A1$5$l$F$$$/9gM}@-(B $B$K$h$k6I=jE*$J:GBg2=86(B
$BM}$O$3$N$h$&$JJQ2=$NM>CO$r;D$9!#$o$l$o$l?M4V$K$O$=$l0J>e$N$3$H$O(B
$BK>$a$J$$!#(B(32$B@a(B)
$B$3$l$i$Nr7o$N$b$H$G!W!V$"$k?M!9$KBP$7(B
$B$F!W$7$+@5Ev2=$G$-$J$$(B($B9gM}E*$Kr7o2<$K$"$j!"IaJW2=2DG=@-MW7o$r(B
$B$"$i$+$8$aG'$a$k
$BIaJW2=2DG=@-MW7o$K$D$$$F$N65/4K$/$J$k$N$b<+A3$J$3$H$G$"$k!"$H$$$&$3$H$K$J$k2D(B
$BG=@-$,$"$k$h$&$K;W$o$l$k!#$3$N2DG=@-$rGS=|$9$k$3$H$O$G$-$k$N$+!#$=$l$H(B
$B$b!"$=$N$h$&$J2DG=@-$O$"$k$7!"$"$C$F$h$$$N$@!"$H
3.$B%X%"$NO)@~$r$$$+$J$k0UL#$G!V7Q>5!W$9$k$N$+(B
$B2A$K$D$$(B
$B$F$G$"$k!#%X%"$NIaJW2=2DG=@-MW7o$,8+D>$5$l$k$J$i!"%X%"$K$h$k8yMx$5$l$k$G$"$m$&!#%X%"$N8yMx
$B
($B0zMQ(B)$B$o$?$7$O!"D9G/%X%"$NJ,@ONQM}3X$NO)@~>e$GNQM}3X$NLdBj(B
$B$r9M$(!">r7o$D$-$GH`$NIaJW2=2DG=@-$N
$B$7$+$7$J$,$i!"JL$N2U=j$G$O!V%X%"$NO)@~!W$r0MA3$H$7$FI>2A$9$kLL$b8+
($B0zMQ(B)$B0l8@$G8@$((B $B$P!"$o$?$7$N5,HONQM}3X$N9=A[$O!"%7%8%&%#%C%/$d%X%"$N8yMx5$9$k$,!"?J2=E*;kE@$H!V8BDj$5$l$?9gM}@-!W$N9M$($r
$B%X%"$N5DO@$K$^$@L%NO$,$"$k$H$9$l$P!"$=$l$O$I$NItJ,$G$"$k$N$+!#%X%"$,8yMx2A$9$Y$-E@$,$"$k!"$H8+$F$*$i$l$k$N$@$m$&$+!#$3$l$,!";d$,65
$B;d<+?H$O!"IaJW2=2DG=@-MW7o$K$D$$$F$NFb0f65$7$KBP$7$F0[O@$O(B
$B$J$$!#$+$J$j87L)$JIaJW2=2DG=@-MW7o$rG'$a$k?M$b$$$l$P!"6K$a$FMx8JE*$J$$(B
$B$7=8CDE*$GF;FAE*G[N8$r3HD%$7$h$&$H$7$J$$?M$bB8:_$7B3$1$k$@$m$&!"$H$$$&(B
$B$3$H$K$b0[O@$O$J$$!#$7$+$7!";d$O!"!VIaJW2=2DG=@-MW7o$rG'$a$k/?t$N?M!9(B
$B$r!X@bF@!Y$9$k$3$H$OD|$a$6$k$r$($J$$!W$H$$$&7kO@(B($BFb0f65CO$,$"$k$,(B)$B$K4JC1$KC#$7$?$/$O(B
$B$J$$$N$G$"$k!#$=$&$7$?!VIaJW2=2DG=@-MW7o$rG'$a$k$l$KF;FAE*$K$J$k$h$&@bF@$G$-$k$d$jJ}$,$b$7$"$k$J$i$P!"(B
$B;d$O$=$N$h$&$J$d$jJ}$r;Y;}$7$?$$!#$=$N$h$&$J$d$jJ}$H$7$F;d$,CmL\$9$k$N(B
$B$O!"Gn0&E*$JM_5a$r$b$D?M$HMx8JE*$JM_5a$r$b$D?M$H$rJL!9$K9M;!$7!"!V$$$:(B
$B$l$N%?%$%W$N?M$G$"$C$F$b!"9gM}E*$K9M$($k$J$i$P2?$i$+$NF;FABN7O$r$b$D$3(B
$B$H$r(B($B$=$l$>$lJL$NM}M3$G(B)$B;Y;}$9$k$O$:$G$"$j!"$=$l$O$*$=$i$/(B($BJL!9$NM}M3(B
$B$+$i;Y;}$5$l$k$K$b$+$+$o$i$:(B)$B8yMx
$BJ88%(B
- $B%7%s%,!
- $B%I%%!&%t%!(B-$B%k!"(BF. (1998)$B!XMx8JE*$J%5%k!"B>?M$r;W$$$d$k%5%k!Y(B($B@>EDMxDg!&F#0f(B $BN1H~Lu(B)$B!"Ap;W
- $B%X%"!"(BR.M. (1994)$B!XF;FAE*$K9M$($k$3$H!Y!"R&Ap=qK
- $B1|LnK~N$;R(B(1999)$B!X%7%8%&%#%C%/$H8=Be8yMx
- $B1vLnC+M40l(B(1984)$B!X2ACMM}G0$N9=B$!YElMN7P:Q?7Js
- $BFb0fAZ<7(B(1974)$B!VNQM}H=CG$NIaJW2=2DG=@-$K$D$$$F!W!X?MJ83XJs!Y(B38$B!"(B 1974$B!#(B
- $BFb0fAZ<7(B(1988)$B!X<+M3$NK!B'!&Mx32$NO@M}!Y!"%_%M%k%t%!=qK
- $BFb0fAZ<7(B(1996)$B!X?J2=O@$HNQM}!Y!"@$3&;WA[
- $BFb0fAZ<7(B(1998-9)$B!VF;FA5/8;O@$+$i?J2=NQM}3X$X!W!"(B1998-9$B!#(B
- $B;34_=SCK(B(1998)$B!X?.Mj$N9=B$!Y!"El5~Bg3X=PHG2q!"(B1998$B!#(B
- Brandt, R. B. (1979) A Theory of the Good and the Right, Oxford: Clarendon Press.