$B%8%c%9%F%#%s!&%!<%/%j!pJs
(Justin Oakley, `Varieties of Virtue Ethics and Its Relevance in An Information Society': Summary)

$BNQM}3X(B4$B2s@8(B $B4_ED8yJ?(B

1$B>O!!FANQM}$NK\
(a) $B$"$k9T0Y$,@5$7$$(B $B"N(B $BM-FA$J@-3J$r;}$D9T0Yu67$K$$$$F$=$N9T0Y$r9T$&$@$m$&!#(B

$B9T0Y$N@5Ev2=$K$$$$F!"2?$i$+$N7A$G@-3J$,M%0L$K$"$k!#$3$l$O%+%s%H
$B$^$:!"(B(a)$B$,Ds<($9$k4p=`$K30E!&FbE$N(B2$BDL$j$,$"$k$3$H$r;XE&$7$F$$3(B $B$&!#30E4p=`$O!"M-FA$J@-3J$r;}$D9T0Y
$B
$BM=A[$C$F9T0Y$9$k$3$H$,I,MW$@(B "$B$H$$$&7A$G9T0Y
$B$7$+$7!"%+%s%HN;?$9$k$+$H$$$&>o<1E8+2r$+$iFA$rF3$-=P$7$?$j(B($B5AL3$KH?$7!"Mx1W$r:GBg(B $B2=$7B;$M$F$b!">N;?$5$l$kFA$,$"$k(B)$B$9$k!#(B

(b) $BA1$5$O@5$7$5$K@h9T$9$k!#(B

$B2ACM$dA1$5$,$I$s$J$b$N$+7h$a$F$+$i$G$J$$$H!"$I$N$h$&$J9T0Y$,@5$7$$(B $B$+$b@bL@$G$-$J$$!#=>$C$F!"FANQM}$O$I$A$i$+$H$$$&$H5AL3O@E$G$O$J$/L\E(B $BO@E$G$"$k!#%+%s%H
(c) $BFA$OJ#?t$NFb:_EA1$G$"$j!"C10l$N$b$N$K$O4T85$G$-$J$$!#(B

$BFA$O!"$C$F!"A1$r2w$K0l85E$K4T85$9$k%?%$%W$N8yMx
(d) $BFA$O5R4QE$KA1$$!#(B

$BFA$NA1$5$O!"FA$KBP$7$FM?$($i$l$k8D!9$NM}M3IU$1$K0MB8$7$F$$$k$N$G$"$C(B $B$F!"A[$N9T0Y
(e) $B9T0Y
$BFAM}O@$O!"FCDj$NA1$rFCDj$N9T0Yl9g!"F1$8(BA$B;a$KBP$9$k?F@Z$G$"$C(B $B$F$b!"$=$l$,(BB$B;a$K$h$k9T0Y$@!"$H$$$&$3$H$,M'>p$H$$$&9T0Yp(B $B$H$$$&FA$K$h$C$F@5Ev2=$5$l$k$3$H$b$"$k!#$3$NE@$G$O!"FAM}O@$O!"9T0Y
(f) $B@5$7$/9T0Y$9$k$3$H$O!"A1$N:GBg2=$rMW5a$7$J$$!#(B

$B;d$NM'>p$rB>p$h$j$bBg;v$K$7$F$h$$$H$-!"FANQM}$,MW5a$9$k$3$H$O!";d$NM'>p$r:GBg2=$9$k$3$H$d!";d$NM'>p$,:G$bA1$/$"$k$3$H$G$O$J$/!"M'?M4X78$r$D$+$5$I$k5,HO$K>H$i$7$FM'>p$,M%$l$F$$$k$3$H$K2a$.$J$$!#(B

2$B>O!!@8L?NQM}3XEy$X$NFANQM}E%"%W%m!<%A(B

$B?M9)G%?1Cf@d$K$D$$$F(B($B%O!<%9%H%O%&%9(B)

$BEAE}E$J!"Jl?F$HB[;y$N8"Mx$N6%9g$H$$$&5DO@$O!"?M9)G%?1Cf@d$NF;FA@-(B $B$H$OL54X78$G$"$k!#$"$k=w@-$,?M9)G%?1Cf@d$r9T$J$&$H7h?4$7$?$=$N7hCG$NF;(B $BFA@-$O!"7hCG$N:]$KH`=w$,<($7$?@-3J$,$I$s$J$b$N$G$"$k$+$KBg$-$/0MB8$9$k!#(B $BNc$($P!"309q$G5Y2K$r2a$4$9$?$a$KG%?1(B7$B%v7n$NB[;y$rCf@d$9$k$H7hCG$9$k$N(B $B$ONdC8$G<+8JCf?4E$G$"$k$H$+!"L$@.G/$N=w@-$,!"Jl?F$K$J$k?4@Q$b$j$,$G$-(B $B$F$$$J$$$H$$$&M}M3$+$iCf@d$r9T$J$&$J$i!"<+J,$N8=:_$N@.D9CJ3,$K$D$$$F$N(B $BE,@Z$J8,5u$5$r<($9$3$H$K$J$k!"$H$+!#(B

$BCf@d$N7hDj$,IT@5$J9T0Y$H$J$k>l9g$NM}M3$OBg$-$/J,$1$F(B2$B$D$"$k!#(B1$B$D$O!"?F$G$"$k$3$H$,!"$I$N$h$&$JFb:_E2ACM$d!"?M@8$r2V3+$+$;$k$?$a$N=EMW@-$r;}$D$+!"$H$$$&G'<1$,7gG!$7$F$$$k$3$H!#?7$7$$?M4V$N@8L?$rCG$A@Z$k$3$H$,?<9o$G$"$k$H$$$&G'<1$,7gG!$7$F$$$k$3$H!#(B

$B0B3Z;`$K$D$$$F(B($B%U%C%H(B)

$B;`$K$?$$$HM_5a$9$k$@$1$G$O!";`$O$=$N?M$K$H$C$F$NA1$H$O$J$i$J$$!#;`$,$=$N?M$K$H$C$F$NA1$H$J$j$&$k$N$O!"$=$N?M$N@8$,:GDc8B$N4pK\E$J?M4V$NA1(B($B$?$H$($P<+N'(B,$BM'>p(B,$B@:?@E$J1g=u(B)$B$r7g$/>l9g$@$1$G$"$k!#(B

"$B;&$9$3$H(B"$B$H(B"$B;`$J$;$k$3$H(B"$B$N0c$$$NJ,@O(B:$B:GDc8B$N4pK\E$J?M4V$NA1$r7g$$$??M$,!";&$5$l$?$$$H?4$+$i4j$&>l9g!"@55A$NFA$H;|A1$NFA$O$H$b$K$=$N9T0Y$r5vMF$9$k!#0lJ}!"4j$o$J$$>l9g!";|A1$NFA$O;&$9$3$H$r5v$7!"@55A$NFA$O$=$&$9$k$3$H$r6X$8$k(B("$B;&$9$3$H(B"$B$H(B"$B;`$J$;$k$3$H(B"$B$N0c$$$O$=$NE@$K$"$k(B)$B!#(B

$B@lLg2HNQM}$K$D$$$F(B

$B@lLg2H$N?&6H$NK\$NFA$N$f$(!#$7$+$7!"FA$K4pAC$rCV$/$h$j$b!"5AL3O@E!&8yMx

3$B>O!!FANQM}$KBP$7$F$7$P$7$P$J$5$l$k(B2$B$D$NHcH=(B

1. $BFA$N35G0$O!"@5$7$5$N4p=`$N4pAC$H$7$FLrN)$D$[$I==J,$KL@$i$+$G>\$7$$$b$N$J$N$+!#(B

(i) $B2?$,4pK\E$JFA$+!"$I$s$J?M$,M-FA$J9T0Y (ii) $BM-FA$J9T0Y$NFA$r;}$D?M$,$J$9$@$m$&9T0Y$r$J$9$N$,@5$7$$$N$+!"?F@Z$NFA$r;}$D?M$,$J$9$@$m$&9T0Y$r$J$9$N$,@5$7$$$N$+!#(B
(iii) $B$=$7$F!"M-FA$J?M$J$i$3$&$9$k$@$m$&!"$H$$$&$3$H$r2f!9$O$I$&$d$C$FCN$k$N$+!#(B
(iv) $B$^$?!"$3$l$,@5$7$$!"$rCN$k$h$j$b@h$K!"$=$l$r$9$k?M$,M-FA$@!"$rCN$k$3$H$O$G$-$k$N$@$m$&$+!#C/$,M-FA$J?M$G$"$k$+$r7h$a$k$?$a$K$=$N?M$N9T0Y$N@5$7$5$r7h$a$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$$J$i!"(B(a)$B$O={4D$k$j$k!#(B(b $B
H?O@(B:

(iv) $BM-FA$J9T0Y (iii) $BFANQM}3Xu67$GM-FA$J9T0Y\$7$$@bL@$rM?$($k$3$H$K@.8y$7$F$$$k!#(B
(i)(ii) $BFANQM}$O(B,$BM-FA$J?MJ$O$I$s$J?M$G$J$K$r$9$k$+$K$D$$$F!"$?$@0l$D$N@5$7$$@bL@$,$"$k$H2. $BM-FA$J@-3J$r$b$D9T0Y
$B$-$o$a$FM-FA$J@-3J$r$b$D?M!9$,!"M-FA$J@-3JFCD'$N$;$$$GIT@5$J9T0Y$KF3$+$l$k$3$H$b$"$k!#A10U$"$k0ep?4$"$k?M$,;|A1$K:b;:$r$D$.9~$s$G2HB2$rIO:$$K4Y$l$k!"$J$I!#(B
$BH?O@(B:

$BFA$r5,@)EM}A[(B(regulative ideals)$B$H$7$F9M$($l$P!"A1$$F05!$d0U?^$+(B $B$i$J$5$l$?9T0Y$G$"$C$F$b!"?M$,;Y;}$9$kBn1[@-$N4p=`$KC#$7$J$$$+$b$7$l$J(B $B$$!"$H$$$&2DG=@-$rG'$a$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#M-FA$J?M$b!"MM!9$JM}M3$+$i!"<+J,(B $B$N5,@)EM}A[$,L?$8$k$H$$j9T0Y$9$k$N$K<:GT$9$k$3$H$,$"$k!#$@$,!"FANQM}(B $B$N5,@)EM}A[$O$=$l$G$b$J$9T0YI>2A$N4p=`$rDs6!$9$k!#$3$N4p=`$+$i!"A1$$(B $BF05!$d0U?^$O@5$7$$9T0Y$NI,MW>r7o$G$"$k$,==J,>r7o$G$O$J$$!"$HM}2r$G$-$k!#(B
$B:FHcH=(B:

$BM-FA$J@-3JFCD'$,7g$1$F$$$k$H$$$&;vNc0J30$K$b!"M-FA$J@-3JFCD'$rK~B-(B $B$K=,F@$7$F$$$k$N$K$=$l$G$b$J$0-$^$?$OIT@5$H;W$o$l$k$d$j$+$?$G9T0Y$9$k!"(B $B$H$$$&;vNc$,$"$k!#(B

$B:FH?O@(B:

$B$=$N$h$&$J;vNc$O6KC<2a$.$F!"FAM}O@$X$NH?Nc$K$J$k$+$I$&$+5?$o$7$$!#(B $BNc$($P!"L5
$BNQM}3X7$/9T0Y$r$J$7$?$H$7$F$b!"M-FA$J@-3JFCD'$+$i(B $B9T0Y$7$F$$$F!"$+$D!"$=$N8m$C$??.G0$rJz$$$?$3$H$K$bMn$AEY$,$J$+$C$?>l9g!"(B $B$=$N9T0Y$,IT@5$+$I$&$+$OA4$/L@$i$+$G$J$$!#(B

$B0J>e$N$h$&$K!"FAM}O@$KBP$9$kHcH= Last modified: Tue Sep 19 15:33:23 JST 2000